What Cut Of Corned Beef Is Better?

Make no mistake about it. The point cut is the best cut of corned beef. In order to ensure juiciness, tenderness, and flavor, this cut has more marbling. Additionally, it has more fat, which preserves the corned beef’s moisture.

When it’s time to make that St. If you’re making corned beef for St. Patrick’s Day, one of the first questions on your mind probably is: Should I buy a point or flat cut? I learned the answer during my time in culinary school. But this was after several failed tries.

I’ll discuss why I believe the point cut is the best for corned beef in this article. Additionally, I’ll explain the difference between the point cut and flat cut and how to prepare your favorite St. Patrick’s Day corned beef.

The flat cut is the preferred cut for corned beef, but the whole brisket is used often as well. If you are trying to make the perfect looking meal for corned beef, then make sure you pick up the flat. If you’re making hash or corned beef for reubens, then you can use either and have great results.

Differences Between Point Cut vs Flat Cut

To understand their differences, it is necessary to first understand what a brisket is. The brisket is a beef cut taken from the lower breast or pectoral muscles of a cow. It is located behind the foreshank and beneath the five ribs. These areas receive good exercise because they bear the majority of the animal’s weight. This is why, though budget-friendly, this cut is tough.

Due to its large size (8 to 16 pounds), the brisket is once more divided into two cuts: the point cut and flat cut.

The point cut, also referred to as brisket point, second cut, and deckle point, is taken from the end of the brisket above the middle layer of fat, as its name implies. It is easily identified by the connective tissue and marbling of fat that runs along its length.

Comparatively, point cut is leaner than flat cut (also known as first and round cut). It does, however, have a thin layer of fat known as a fat cap that continues to keep it moist.

Here is a breakdown of how these brisket cuts differ from one another specifically:

Point Cut Is Smaller and Thicker Than Flat Cut

The size and shape of these two cuts are the primary distinctions between them.

When compared to a flat cut, the point cut looks uneven. It’s smaller than the flat cut, but thicker in comparison. In general, it does not have that much meat.

On the other hand, a flat cut looks even and uniform and is leaner and more meaty. It weighs between 5 and 10 pounds and is precisely 1 to 2 inches thick, as opposed to 5 to 7 pounds for a point cut.

Because the flat cut of corned beef maintains its shape better, some people prefer it. Due to its leaner composition, it disintegrates less than the point cut, which becomes more tender as it cooks. Due to its even and uniform appearance, it slices well and is more aesthetically pleasing.

Point Cut Has More Fat Marbling, Flat Cut Is Leaner

You can tell right away that the point cut is more heavily marbled with fat and connective tissue. The point cut is performed above the middle layer of fat, whereas the flat cut is performed below it, as was previously mentioned. Due to this, the flat cut, which has more meat, has less fat than the point cut, which has more.

Make sure to remove the thin layer of fat from a point cut before cooking. But be careful not to remove all of it because it adds flavor. Cutting some off would get rid of the mushy and slimy mouthfeel, but saving some will give your brisket an umami flavor. In light of this, it is advised to trim the fat cap by about 1/4 to 1/2 inch while retaining some fat.

Point Cut Has More Beefy Flavor Than Flat Cut

The brisket portion of the beef is where the point cut and flat cut come from. However, they still differ from one another in flavor in noticeable ways.

Because of the additional fat, the point cut has a more beefy flavor overall. For sandwiches like this BBQ pulled beef burger, this cut is typically ground or shredded.

For corned beef, however, the flat cut is preferred because it slices well. Even though it has less flavor than point cut, you can still improve it by adding spices and seasonings while the food is slowly cooking.

Point Cut vs Flat Cut: Which Is Better?

The following are some of the questions that will help you choose between the corned beef point cut and flat cut now that you are aware of how they contrast in terms of size and flavor:

What Is the Best Cut for Corned Beef?

The flat cut, which has an even and uniform shape and is visually appealing on dinner tables, is the best cut for corned beef. With less fat and connective tissues, it also slices up evenly and nicely.

This brisket cut is the preferred option for those who want a beautiful plate of corned beef and cabbage, a common dish served during St. Patrick’s Day.

Which Cut of Corned Beef Is More Tender?

The best cut of corned beef is point cut if you prefer more tender and juicy meat. It is more flavorful, soft, and juicy than flat cut because it has more marbling and fat. However, because both cuts of meat are tough, slow cooking techniques using low heat are necessary.

Which Cut of Corned Beef Is More Expensive?

The majority of chefs and food enthusiasts look for point cuts that are tender, flavorful, and have juicy meat. Because of this, the point cut is more expensive than the other brisket because it is regarded as the more premium cut.

For the majority of home cooks, flat cut is a more practical and affordable choice. Additionally, it’s the most prevalent brisket cut you’ll find in the supermarket.

Where to Buy Brisket Flat Cut and Point Cut?

A whole brisket can weigh up to 16 pounds, which a typical grocery store typically does not stock. However, some supermarkets do offer flat cuts and point cuts.

You must visit a butcher in order to purchase the entire brisket. Keep in mind that a flat cut alone weighs five to ten pounds, while a point cut weighs five to seven pounds. Therefore, one serving of brisket from one cut is more than enough.

How to Cook Brisket Point Cut and Flat Cut

The meat in corned beef point cut vs. flat cut can occasionally be tough. Because the point cut doesn’t dry out as much as the flat cut, it is ideal for grilling or smoking. There are a few cooking techniques you can use to make your corned beef and cabbage tender and moist with meat that pulls apart easily, though that could easily change if you know how to prepare it properly.

First, you can try the braising method. This old-fashioned method involves searing your meat on high heat without fully cooking it. The braising liquid, which frequently contains wine, barbecue sauce, broth, and canned tomatoes, is then added to the meat and transferred to a stock pot to stew. Basically, this technique makes the beef tender enough to cut with a fork.

In addition to braising, you can also try slow-cooking techniques with the aid of your oven or slow-cooker. Additionally, if you want to prepare the well-known smoked brisket, which is a hit in the American Southwest, smoking is a popular alternative.

Odette works as a content creator and proofreader during the day and expresses her creative side as a poet and singer at night. She was formerly a contributor to a publication and occasionally serves as a mentor. She enjoys how helping others by sharing a small portion of her life and journey with them She also enjoys encouraging other curlies to embrace their natural curls because she is a curl ambassador. Additionally, she enjoys cooking for those she cares about as a random act of kindness. Although she recently went through a phase of loving Japanese and Korean food, this girl adores pasta and French cuisine.

Related Articles Dry Sherry Substitute: 9 Alternatives You Should Try Licor 43: An Amazing Vanilla Liqueur You Should Definitely Try Silver Tequila vs Gold Tequila: What’s The Difference? Sweet Wines: All About Its Types & Best Brands To Try Winter Melon (Ash Gourd): What Is It and Exciting Ways to Cook It 10 Best Substitutes for Italian Seasoning From Your Pantry Wheat Beer: What Is It and Best Brands to Try Cloves to Minced Garlic Conversion Guide What Is Maraschino Liqueur And Why You Need It In Your Bar Ancho Chile: What Is It, Uses, and Recipes You Can Try  Reposado vs Anejo vs Blanco: Which Is The Best? Parsley vs Cilantro: 4 Main Differences You Should Know

The Difference Between Flat Cut And Point Cut Corned Beef


Which cut of corned beef is the most tender?

Which Corned Beef Cut Is More Tender? Point cut is the best cut of corned beef if you want a more tender and juicy meat. It is more flavorful, soft, and juicy than flat cut because it has more marbling and fat.

Which is better corned beef brisket or flat cut?

The flat cut makes up the majority of the brisket. It’s long and thin, and the top is covered in a layer of fat that keeps the meat moist while it cooks. Most likely, you’ll find this cut in your supermarket because it slices well. Additionally, it’s the ideal brisket cut to use for homemade corned beef.

Which corned beef is better red or grey?

Nitrates, either in the form of sodium nitrate or saltpeter, added to the salty brine that gives brisket its corned taste and flavor, are the cause of the color difference. Red corned beef is much more popular than gray corned beef due to nitrates’ ability to preserve meat and give it a reddish hue.

Leave a Comment