Are Shrimp Really Sentient Creatures? The Surprising Evidence
For centuries, humans have enjoyed eating shrimp and other small crustaceans like prawns without much thought about whether these creatures actually experience pain or have feelings. In popular culture, shrimp are often depicted simply as food But as animal welfare science has advanced, there is now strong evidence that shrimp, as well as other decapod crustaceans like crabs and lobsters, are sentient beings who likely feel pain and emotion.
What Does “Sentient” Actually Mean?
Sentience refers to the capacity to have subjective experiences and feelings. Sentient beings don’t just respond reflexively to stimuli – they actually feel things. Sentience is not the same as self-awareness, which involves an awareness of your own consciousness. An animal can still feel pain or pleasure without being self-aware.
Sentience exists on a spectrum. The sentience and complexity of inner lives varies greatly between different species and even between individuals. We don’t need absolute proof that shrimp are sentient to a human-like degree. If there is a reasonable possibility they feel something consciously, we have an ethical responsibility to avoid inflicting suffering. This concept is called the precautionary principle in animal welfare science.
Scientific Consensus Says Shrimp Are Sentient
In 2021, a major report commissioned by the UK government concluded that decapod crustaceans like shrimp should be regarded as sentient. This built on a 2005 report by the European Food Safety Authority that recommended decapods receive legal protection as animals likely capable of experiencing pain and distress.
Several European countries now recognize decapod sentience in law, including Austria, Switzerland, Norway, and as of 2022, the UK. The scientific evidence clearly indicates shrimp can feel and experience life, even if their experience is different from human experience.
The Neurological Evidence for Shrimp Sentience
Shrimp behavior provides many clues that these animals feel pain consciously. Let’s break down the evidence:
-
Nociceptors – Shrimp have sensory receptors that detect harmful stimuli like predators or electric shocks. This is called nociception.
-
Integrative Brain Centers – Parts of the shrimp brain integrate input from different senses, a key hallmark of sentience.
-
Neural Connections – Those nociceptors connect to the integrative regions.
-
Pain Relief Alters Behavior – When given anesthetics, shrimp reduce behaviors indicating distress.
-
Trade-Offs and Learning – Shrimp show complex learning and make trade-offs between threats and opportunities.
-
Protective Behavior – When injured, shrimp exhibit long-term guarding and grooming of damaged areas.
-
Analgesic Seeking – There is some evidence injured shrimp may prioritize analgesia.
Overall, shrimp neurobiology exhibits many features necessary for a conscious experience of pain.
Shrimp Behavior Also Shows Sentience
Beyond neuroscience, shrimp behavior provides compelling clues into these animals’ inner lives:
-
Avoiding Predators – Shrimp instinctively flee from predators and remembered threats using sophisticated escape behaviors.
-
Responding to Injury – When physically harmed, shrimp immediately tend to their wounded antennae or eyestalks, sometimes for hours.
-
Stress Reactions – Extreme temperatures, toxins, and injuries cause release of stress hormones.
-
Impaired Function After Mutilation – Removing eyestalks blinds shrimp and causes abnormal swimming patterns for long periods.
-
Motivation Changes – Injured shrimp alter behaviors to guard wounded areas and avoid additional harm.
These complex reactions are extremely difficult to explain without positing the existence of conscious feeling. Shrimp don’t just reflexively respond to harm – they act like they consciously want to avoid pain.
The Ethical Implications of Shrimp Sentience
Knowing that shrimp are sentient has profound ethical implications. Humans consume over 40,000 tonnes of shrimp annually in the UK alone. We largely treat these animals as mindless commodities. However, the evidence clearly shows shrimp have a capacity for suffering.
Most shrimp are farmed in overcrowded, filthy conditions. They have their eyes sliced out or brains mutilated without pain relief to force constant breeding. These horrific practices are only possible if we believe shrimp exist as automata, incapable of conscious experience.
Once we understand these animals feel pain much like we do, such routine cruelty becomes unconscionable. We must rethink our ethical obligations toward shrimp and similar creatures. Rather than relegating them to the category of unfeeling objects, we should provide the same legal protections given to vertebrates like birds and mammals.
That doesn’t mean eliminating shrimp consumption immediately. But it does necessitate developing more humane and sustainable farming practices that prioritize animal welfare rather than maximum productivity. And it requires minimizing unnecessary suffering in our sourcing and consumption of shrimp, transitioning toward plant-based seafood alternatives.
We can no longer justify the status quo based on an outdated understanding of crustaceans as basically mindless robots. Shrimp feel pain. The science leaves little room for reasonable doubt. It is up to us to evolve our ethics and behavior to align with this truth, rather than denying the evidence because it challenges old dogmas. Any other path forward is simply self-serving rationalization.
The Evolution of Pain
It is against the law in the UK to treat prawns and shrimp as “animals,” according to the Animal Welfare Act 2006. As such, they aren’t legally seen as a being that needs a single welfare protection law. So, the real question is whether or not we care about the welfare of prawns and shrimp based on science or our own ideas about these small animals.
Studies have repeatedly shown that aquatic animals such as fish, lobster, prawns and shrimp do feel pain. Evolution has given animals on earth the ability to feel pain as a means of self-preservation. Humans quickly learn that it hurts to get too near fire, and we therefore avoid doing so. Thanks to our pain receptors, we’re better equipped to protect our bodies from potential burns, damaged limbs and other injuries that would put our life at risk. People with congenital insensitivity to pain (CIP), a rare condition in which the afflicted human cannot feel physical pain, commonly die in childhood because their injuries or illnesses go unnoticed until it’s too late. Burn injuries are extremely common because they don’t have that pain telling them to ‘move away!’ We hate the feeling of pain, but that’s exactly why we need it to survive.
One thing that is true for all animals is that pain is a key factor in the survival of species. If an animal didn’t feel pain, they wouldn’t do anything when a predator started attacking or eating them. Such animal species wouldn’t last long. From an evolutionary point of view, pain in animals makes absolute sense.
You may still be unconvinced that a tiny animal like a prawn can feel pain. Research show otherwise. In one such study, Glass Prawns had a noxious substance applied to their antennae. The afflicted prawns immediately reacted, grooming their antennae extensively, trying to remove the substance in an attempt to remove the pain. As soon as a local anaesthetic was applied and the pain was removed, they stopped grooming so obsessively, showing that they clearly felt pain and did what they could to alleviate it right up until it was numbed. Researchers found that prawns show signs of pain, in many similar ways to which we do.
Do prawns have a central nervous system?
“But prawns don’t have central nervous systems,” you may say in response. “So they can’t feel pain, really. ” It is true that prawns don’t have central nervous systems. But Professor Robert Elwood, who has spent decades studying the fascinating lives of crustaceans, doesn’t agree with the idea that having a central nervous system is the only way to show that you can feel pain. He says that telling an animal it can’t feel pain because it doesn’t have the same biology as humans is like telling them they can’t see because it doesn’t have a visual cortex.
He’s absolutely right – we can at the very least all agree that prawns have vision. It doesn’t mean they can’t see just because their species evolved to see with a different system than humans, who have a visual cortex. In the same way, an animal can feel pain in more ways than one besides having a neuronal system.
This is understood by the European Food Safety Authority, an independent body that bases its conclusions on scientific research. For over 15 years, the EFSA has been calling for prawns and shrimp to be placed in the same category as animals such as chickens, pigs and sheep, who are understood to feel pain.
@TheNutrivore Reacting To @VeganGains On Shrimp Sentience || @2AMVegan’s Video
Are octopus sentient?
The scope of the Animal Welfare (Sentience) Bill has today been extended to recognise lobsters, octopus and crabs and all other decapod crustaceans and cephalopod molluscs as sentient beings.
Are penaeid shrimps sentient molluscs & decapod crustaceans?
The Act recognised the sentience of cephalopod molluscs and decapod crustaceans (including shrimps). There is relatively strong evidence that larger decapod crustaceans (i.e. true crabs) are sentient . Unfortunately compared to larger decapods, penaeid shrimps have barely been studied .
Are octopus and crayfish sentient?
The report by experts at the London School of Economics looked at 300 scientific studies to evaluate evidence of sentience, and they concluded that cephalopods (such as octopuses, squid and cuttlefish) and decapods (such as crabs, lobsters and crayfish) should be treated as sentient beings.
Are molluscs sentient?
UK – In April 2022, the UK Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act passed through the UK Govt., becoming law. The Act recognised the sentience of cephalopod molluscs and decapod crustaceans (including shrimps). There is relatively strong evidence that larger decapod crustaceans (i.e. true crabs) are sentient .