Are Shrimp the Bugs of the Sea? A Closer Look at Shrimp vs Bugs

This week, we’re going to dive right into crustaceans and how they are related to insects. But that’s not all. Lets also take a closer look at lobsters and learn some interesting history.

Welcome to episode 63 of Insects for fun! Only today we’re not talking about insects exclusively. This episode is a bridge to all the other episodes about crustaceans. There are a lot of them, and I don’t want to keep explaining how they relate to each other every time. SO! Here we go (underwater bubbles).

Do you remember the episode where I said that not all bugs are insects but all bugs are insects? Well, I have another one for you. Not all crustaceans are insects (HUH), but all insects are crustaceans. Also, spiders, scorpions, millipedes, centipedes, and horseshoe crabs are not crustaceans. This means that lobsters, shrimp, and crabs are more closely related to insects than to arachnids and those other creepy crawly arthropods. Let’s go back in time to where it all began which would be the Cambrian period. At this point in time, the earth did have land masses, but Pangea was not there. These land masses were very, very empty. Almost all life was still in the ocean and it was here that Crustaceans first came into existence.

What do crustaceans and insects have in common? They both have chitin-based exoskeletons and begin life as eggs and go through a series of molts to become adults. They also both have compound eyes and antennae! Yes, even crabs have antennae, and what’s even crazier is that crustaceans have two pairs of antennae, while insects only have one. But the similarities go deeper than this, and by that I’m referring to their insides. In order to carry oxygen, they both use the same proteins, and their circulatory systems are run by the same peptides. I think it’s safe to say that yes. Insects are crustaceans, and when we eat lobster, shrimp, and crab, we’re really just eating big bugs that live in the ocean.

But are lobsters really just roaches of the sea? Where did that myth come from? In the United States, lobsters were once called “the poor man’s chicken” or even “cockroaches of the sea.” In the 1600s and 1700s, lobsters’ full flavor had not yet been discovered, and people did not know how tasty they could be. There were so many lobsters that they washed up on the shore that no one knew what to do with them since they weren’t going to eat them. But the reason lobsters began to really pique people’s interest started with the transportation system. As more and more railroads were built and more and more people rode trains for longer periods of time, food had to be made available. What better food to offer than cheap, common lobster? As more and more people started eating lobster, they became interested in how to cook it, and now here we are. Lobster is considered a delicacy and fetches a high price.

This is what we know about crustaceans and the history of lobsters in the United States. Take a look at what a lobster really is and decide for yourself if they are, in fact, overpriced cockroaches.

There are different kinds of lobsters, and some crustaceans that are called lobsters are not at all lobsters. Today we are going to talk about clawed lobsters, which are in the family Nephropidae. There are only about 54 of them, which I find a bit odd, but I think there must be more since everyone says we know more about the sun than the oceans on Earth. These clawed lobsters have 10 legs but only 8 are used for walking. We eat big claws, which are made up of just one pair of three legs. The front three pairs all have claws.

Now here’s where it starts to get quite familiar… the body of a lobster contains three segments. It has a head, a thorax, and an abdomen. In most crustaceans, the head and thorax are joined together in a cephalothorax. Lobsters also have big compound eyes and three sets of antennae. The two long ones are used to feel the ground, and the others pick up chemicals and smells in the water. Some people may be curious about the smaller legs that a lobster has under its tail. They are called pleopods or swimmerets, and they help the lobster swim!

Most clawed lobsters are big, measuring between 25 and 50 cm (10 and 20 inches). I’m sure many of us have seen one type of them before, but it depends on where the species lives. It stands to reason that deep sea lobsters are smaller than big red Maine lobsters, for instance. Even the lobsters in Japan are pretty small. In fact, I think most things here are smaller than they are in the U.S.

And speaking of where they live, these lobsters can be found in all oceans, on sandy, rocky, and muddy floors, close to the shore or out past the continental shelf into the deep. The bigger lobsters are found farther out. Most of the time, lobsters move around by walking on the floor, but when they need to, they can move pretty quickly! To get away, they flick their tails and push themselves backwards, and their fastest speed was recorded at 11mph. They don’t just use their legs for walking though. They actually taste with the front walking legs. They also chew with their stomach, not their mouth. In their stomachs, they have something called a gastric mill, which is basically a food roller that breaks down everything. That’s why lobsters have big claws: they can’t just swallow things whole like birds do. They usually rip their food into smaller pieces before crushing them even more in their stomachs. The claws are used to open and eat crabs, clams, mussels, and sometimes even other lobsters. They can put up to 100 pounds of force on them.

And now let’s look at how long a lobster lives. There are rumors that these animals are incredibly tough, like roaches, and that they are biologically immortal! Let’s look at the facts. People and other animals are made to break down because as our cells divide and are born again, a small part of them doesn’t come back until the cells stop dividing altogether. This small tip at the end of our cells coding is called a telomere. If we compare this to fishing, it’s like never being able to replace the line on your rod. Since you don’t have a swivel, you have to cut your line just a bit every time you switch lures, and it keeps getting shorter until you can’t fish anymore. Lobsters, on the other hand, have an enzyme called telemorase that acts as a swivel so they can change lures without taking any line off. So yeah. Lobsters are in fact biologically immortal. If lobsters get more fertile as they age, then why do they die? Because as they age and grow, they have to keep shedding their skin, which takes more energy and calories. This means that lobsters don’t die of old age, but from being too tired to keep going. At some point, they can’t get enough food to replace their shells, and that’s the end of it. So, in our first example, the lobster’s fishing rod gets thicker and thicker until you can’t even lift it to go fishing. They can also regenerate limbs, but it’s going to take some time. For example a one pound lobster will need about 5 years to regrow one of its larger claws. And yes lobsters feel pain! I don’t care what chefs say or anyone in the food industry. They have sensitive hairs all over their body and an incredibly complex nervous system. There is so much misleading information made publicly available by people who really don’t have a clue. On the Maine Lobster Company website, I read that because bugs and lobsters don’t have brains, they don’t feel pain. (dumb dumb dumb dumb).

We’ve already talked about lobsters’ history as a food source, but did you know that they get grades? When a lobster is caught, it gets one of three grades: new shell, hard shell, or old shell. The price of each grade goes up with the hardness. The reason is that harder lobsters can be shipped further away, but the meat is coarser. New shell lobsters are incredibly fragile and cannot be transported far. The meat is tender and more sweet when compared with harder shelled lobsters. It’s a fun fact that lobster shells can be used to make golf balls! They look the same, but they only have 70% of the power.

It’s time to decide if lobsters are really roaches of the sea (drum roll): the answer is no! They look a lot alike, but they are not related enough on the family tree or even in appearance to be thought of as the same thing. There are definitely sea roaches though but that’s for another episode….

That’s all for today’s topic! If you liked the episode or the podcast, please rate and review it so that more people can find it. If you want bonus episodes about insect news and other interesting discoveries, you can find them at Patreon, along with vlogs. com/insects for fun. You can send me a listener submission on Instagram at insect(number)fun or through a Facebook message. You can also email me at [email protected]. com.

Shrimp are a beloved seafood but some refer to them as the “bugs of the sea.” This comparison likely stems from certain similarities shrimp share with land-dwelling insects. However shrimp are actually crustaceans, not bugs.

In this article, we’ll take a closer look at shrimp vs bugs – their similarities, differences, and why shrimp aren’t really the bugs of the sea after all.

Shrimp and Bug Similarities

There are a few key traits shrimp and bugs have in common that lead some to liken shrimp to underwater bugs:

Exoskeletons – Both shrimp and insects have hard outer shells called exoskeletons made of chitin. This armor-like covering protects their inner organs.

Segmented Bodies – Shrimp and bugs have bodies clearly divided into segments This segmentation improves mobility

Multiple Pairs of Jointed Appendages – They have several pairs of jointed legs and mouthparts used for movement and feeding.

Omnivorous Diet – Shrimp and many bugs are omnivores, able to eat both plant and animal matter for food.

Molting Process – As they grow, both shrimp and insects must periodically shed their outer shell in a process called molting.

High Reproductive Rate – They reproduce rapidly, producing large numbers of offspring. Many species have short life spans.

Ability to Transmit Disease – Some shrimp and insects can transmit diseases to humans, like cholera in shrimp and malaria in mosquitos.

Occasional Mass Swarming – Under certain conditions, both shrimp and some insects (like locusts) congregate in massive swarms.

So at a glance, shrimp and bugs appear quite similar creatures. But looks can be deceiving!

Key Differences Between Shrimp and Bugs

While they share some surface similarities, shrimp and bugs belong to completely different taxonomic classifications and have many key differences:

Habitat – Shrimp are aquatic, living in oceans, lakes and rivers, while insects live on land.

Respiration – Shrimp breathe via gills, bugs use internal trachea.

Number of Antennae – Shrimp have two pairs of antennae, bugs just one pair.

Number of Legs – Shrimp have five pairs of legs, bugs have three pairs.

Internal Structure – Shrimp have a heart, brain and digestive tract. Bugs have simpler physiology.

Reproductive Strategy – Shrimp hatch from eggs as planktonic larvae. Bug young resemble tiny adults (nymphs).

Social Behavior – Some shrimp species form social groups. Most bugs are solitary.

Defense Mechanisms – Shrimp use camouflage and burrowing. Bugs rely more on toxins or stingers.

Commercial Value – Shrimp are commercially fished and farmed. Only a few bugs like honeybees and silkworms are utilized.

Culinary Use – Shrimp are a popular seafood. Bugs are rarely eaten in Western cuisine.

So while they may seem closely related at first glance, shrimp and bugs actually have many significant biological differences.

Taxonomic Classification of Shrimp vs Bugs

The taxonomic classification of an organism determines its precise relationship to other living things. This chart shows how shrimp and bugs are categorized:

Shrimp

Kingdom: Animalia

Phylum: Arthropoda

Subphylum: Crustacea

Class: Malacostraca

Order: Decapoda

Bugs/Insects

Kingdom: Animalia

Phylum: Arthropoda

Subphylum: Hexapoda

Class: Insecta

Order: Varies (Diptera, Hemiptera etc)

As you can see, while both are arthropods, shrimp belong to the crustacean subphylum while true bugs and insects belong to the hexapoda subphylum. They are related only at the broadest phylum level. Within that phylum, they diverge into distinct subgroups.

This taxonomic distinction proves that shrimp are not bugs or insects. Calling shrimp “sea bugs” is scientifically inaccurate.

Are Crabs and Lobsters Giant Sea Bugs?

Crabs and lobsters are marine animals that seem bug-like at first glance. But are they really just giant sea bugs?

The answer is no – crabs and lobsters are also crustaceans, closely related to shrimp. Like shrimp, they have:

  • 10 legs
  • Gills for breathing
  • Two pairs of antennae
  • Bodies covered in a hard carapace (shell)

So while they superficially resemble massive underwater bugs, crabs and lobsters are actually more closely related to shrimp than to any insect.

Here are some key differences between crabs/lobsters and insects:

Crabs/Lobsters

  • Marine crustaceans
  • 5 pairs of legs plus front pincers
  • Breathe via gills
  • Hatch from eggs into larvae

Insects

  • Terrestrial bugs
  • 3 pairs of legs
  • Breathe via spiracles
  • Hatch into nymphs from eggs

The bottom line? Crabs, lobsters and shrimp are all crustaceans, not giant sea bugs!

Can Shrimp Transmit Disease Like Bugs?

Some people lump shrimp and bugs together as potential spreaders of illness. Is this concern valid?

A few important points:

  • Some shrimp species can transmit pathogens like cholera bacteria if eaten raw or undercooked. Proper cooking destroys these pathogens.

  • Insects like mosquitos can spread serious illnesses like malaria through biting.

  • However, calling shrimp “sea bugs” due to disease concerns is an overgeneralization. Not every shrimp harbors pathogens, just as not every insect spreads human disease.

  • With proper handling using gloves during prep and thorough cooking, shrimp are safe to eat and not a disease concern.

So while a small risk of illness exists if consuming undercooked or contaminated shrimp, it does not mean shrimp are exactly like infective bugs. Following safe preparation mitigates the risk.

Are Shrimp Pests Like Some Bugs?

In some ecosystems, both shrimp and insects can act as problematic pests:

  • Some shrimp species may detrimentally overpopulate waters, crowding out native species.

  • Locusts and other bugs are well-known for ravaging crops as plagues when their numbers explode.

However, in their natural state and normal numbers, neither shrimp nor bugs are inherently “pests.” They occupy vital niches in coastal marine habitats and terrestrial ecosystems respectively.

It’s typically human disruption that pushes shrimp or insect populations to artificially high pest-like levels. They are not inherently “bad bugs.”

Should Shrimp Be Avoided Like Bugs?

For people with an aversion to land-dwelling bugs, does that mean shrimp should be avoided too?

In short – no! Here’s why:

  • Shrimp are not taxonomically classified as insects or bugs. So there’s no reason those with insect phobias should fear shrimp.

  • Shrimp are cleanly fished from the ocean or raised in farms. Bugs potentially carry dirt or toxins from crawling on the ground.

  • Shrimp have a pleasing taste and texture enjoyed by many. Most insects are unappealing to the Western palate.

  • Allergic reactions to shellfish like shrimp are rare compared to insect sting allergies.

  • Shrimp provide nutrients like protein, vitamins, and omega-3s. Bugs have limited nutritional value by comparison.

  • Cooking kills any potential pathogens in shrimp. Many bugs can immediately inject toxins through bites or stings.

For all these reasons, those averse to terrestrial insects and bugs can confidently eat and enjoy shrimp without associating them with bugs!

At a cursory glance, shrimp do share some attributes with land-based bugs. However, they have key biological differences and are scientifically classified as crustaceans, not insects.

Crabs, lobsters and crayfish are also marine crustaceans rather than giant sea bugs. So calling shrimp “the bugs of the sea” is not accurate.

While shrimp have some pest and disease potential if populations explode, in general they are nutritious and tasty components of coastal ecosystems, not dirty “sea bugs” to avoid.

The next time you enjoy some succulent shrimp, you can rest assured they are not simply underwater insects. Their unique aquatic adaptations and place in the crustacean family set them distinctly apart from any bug!

are shrimp bugs of the sea

Are Crabs, Shrimp and Lobster Underwater BUGS?

Leave a Comment