The age-old question of whether shooting a turkey off the roost is ethical or not continues to spark heated debates among hunters. While some see it as a legitimate hunting tactic others consider it unsporting and unfair to the bird. But before diving into the ethical arguments, let’s first understand the different perspectives.
Why Some Hunters Shoot Turkeys on the Roost:
- Accessibility: For some hunters, especially those with physical limitations, climbing a tree might be the only way to reach a roosting turkey.
- Challenge: Some hunters find the challenge of sneaking up on a sleeping turkey and making a clean shot to be exhilarating.
- Tradition: In some areas, shooting turkeys on the roost has been a long-standing tradition passed down through generations.
Why Others Consider It Unethical:
- Unsporting: Many hunters believe that shooting a sleeping bird is not a fair chase, as the turkey has no chance to defend itself.
- Dangerous: Shooting a turkey out of a tree can be dangerous, as the falling bird could injure the hunter or someone nearby.
- Wasteful: If the hunter misses the shot, the startled turkey might fly away, never to be seen again.
The Legality of Shooting Turkeys on the Roost:
The legality of shooting turkeys on the roost varies from state to state. While it is strictly forbidden in some states, it is perfectly legal in others. It’s crucial to check your local hunting regulations before heading out.
Ethical Considerations:
Even if shooting turkeys on the roost is legal in your state. there are still ethical considerations to ponder:
- Is it a fair chase? Does the turkey have a reasonable chance of escape?
- Is it safe? Are you confident in your ability to make a clean shot and avoid any potential risks?
- Is it necessary? Are there other ways to hunt turkeys that align better with your personal ethics?
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to shoot a turkey on the roost is a personal one. There is no right or wrong answer, as long as you are following the law and acting responsibly. Consider all the factors involved, weigh the ethical implications, and make the choice that feels right for you.
Additional Resources:
- National Wild Turkey Federation: https://www.nwtf.org/
- Your State’s Hunting Regulations: https://www.state.gov/hunting-and-fishing-in-the-united-states/
- Hunting Ethics: https://www.hunter-ed.com/hunting/ethics/
Remember, ethical hunting is about respecting the animal, the environment, and yourself.
Happy hunting!
What’s odd in one state is legal in another . . .
Strange turkey hunting laws are on the books all over the country.
While it is true that you can legally shoot a turkey off its roost in some states, doing so in others could result in your license being revoked. This is where some would argue that something isn’t ethical or sporting just because it’s legal. Naturally, we have the last say when it comes to whether or not “fair chase” tactics are supported by a legal tactic in situations where unusual turkey hunting regulations are in effect.
“Legal aint always right,” some might say.
Whats strange to some is a tradition to others. You can use a turkey dog to find and scatter fall flocks in many states before trying to call them back to your setup. You can even try it in a limited number of spring states according to the American Wild Turkey Hunting Dog Association. As a longtime turkey dogger – well over 20 years now in states where the autumn tradition is allowed – I dont find it strange at all and neither do the fellow dog-handling turkey hunters in my circle.
In Maine “a person may not shoot or shoot at a wild turkey decoy of another person.” In this day and age of hyper-realistic hen and especially full-fan gobbler fakes, this seemingly odd regulation is inserted in the “illegal hunting methods” as a suggestive safety measure.
Check your state’s laws regarding the use of air rifles, turkey dogs, and spears during the spring gobbler season or the fall hunting season before utilizing any of these wild turkey tactics. Any odd hunting laws youd like to share? Comment below.
Steve Hickoff is Realtrees turkey hunting editor and blogger. Although he hasn’t attempted to kill gobblers with a spear or air gun where it’s legal, he feels confident using a 12-gauge
How to Hunt a Turkey off the Roost
FAQ
Can you shoot a turkey while its roosting?
Can you shoot a roosted turkey in Indiana?
What to do if you bump a turkey off the roost?