If you’ve never had the pleasure of eating crawfish before, you are in for a tasty treat. Before you try Cajun dishes with crawfish, you should learn a bit about this small sea creature. Read on to discover what crawfish is, how it tastes, and how you can get the best bite.
A crawfish is a crustacean that looks like a small lobster, measuring between three and six inches long. Like lobsters and crabs, they have a hard shell that protects them and 10 legs, with the front two being bigger claws. These tiny crustaceans live near the shore, but you can find them on the bottom of almost every ocean in the world. When left alone in the wild, crawfish can live as long as 50 years.
Crayfish and lobster – two crustaceans that look so similar yet inhabit different worlds. Lobsters prowl cold, salty ocean floors while crayfish crawl freshwater lakes and rivers.
Given their uncanny resemblance. a common question arises does crayfish taste like lobster?
While not identical these critters share a sweet briny flavor profile that makes crayfish an affordable stand-in for decadent lobster. Let’s explore their tastes side-by-side.
Appearance – Two Peas In A Pod
At first glance, crayfish and lobster look practically identical. They both have long bodies, muscular tails, spiny heads, and thick pairs of claws – hallmarks of the crustacean family.
The best way to tell them apart? Size.
-
Crayfish reach 5-6 inches long and weigh under a pound. They have small, smooth claws.
-
Lobsters grow over 20 inches long and exceeding 5 pounds. Their claws are notably larger and uneven in size.
Beyond size, crayfish sport brighter reds and oranges while lobster shells shade darker green and brown. Still, when cooked, both turn a familiar burnt orange.
Habitat – Distant Underwater Cousins
Crayfish and lobsters live oceans apart:
-
Crayfish frequent freshwater rivers, streams, ponds, and lakes across North America and Europe. They hide under rocks or burrow tunnels near the shore.
-
Lobsters inhabit saltwater oceans off the Atlantic coast of North America and Europe. They dwell on rocky reefs and sandy ocean floors up to 150 feet deep.
So if you’re fishing for dinner in a lake, you’ll catch crayfish. If you drop traps off the ocean docks, you’ll pull up lobster. Remember: freshwater, crayfish – saltwater, lobster.
Diet – Opportunistic Feeders
Both species forage for food at night, feasting on anything edible they can get their claws on.
Crayfish dine on worms, insects, plants, snails, and decomposing animals. Lobsters eat clams, crabs, mussels, fish, and urchins. They use their specialized claws to crush hard shells or shred flesh.
The takeaway? Crayfish and lobsters thrive on protein-rich meals, lending a savory flavor to their meat.
Taste Test – Sweet, Briny, Delicate
Now for the million dollar question: how do crayfish and lobster actually taste?
While some taste discrepancies exist, their core flavors share much in common:
-
Sweetness – Both contain natural sugars that caramelize during cooking, giving a hint of sweetness. Lobster edges out crayfish in sweetness due to its ocean habitat.
-
Briny flavor – Since lobsters live in saltwater, their meat absorbs a distinctly briny quality. Crayfish have a milder freshwater flavor.
-
Delicate texture – Once cooked, their meat offers a tender, flaky texture. Lobster meat feels slightly firmer while crayfish is softer.
Bottom line: Crayfish and lobster taste noticeably similar – sweet, briny, and delicate. Lobster has a saltier ocean flavor while crayfish is milder. The common denominator? Shellfish goodness.
Cheaper Crayfish: An Affordable Swap
Pound for pound, crayfish offer the closest flavor substitute for pricey lobster. Some key advantages:
-
Cost – Crayfish run $4-8 per pound while lobster costs $15-25 per pound – easily 2-3x more!
-
Availability – Crayfish are abundant in lakes and rivers across the U.S. Lobster is limited to East/North Atlantic waters.
-
Prep work – Crayfish take minimal prep beyond boiling or steaming. Lobster requires significant processing.
For penny-pinching seafood lovers, crayfish make an affordable, accessible lobster alternative. Opt for crayfish when craving succulent shellfish on a budget.
Simple Ways To Prepare Crayfish
Ready to cook up some crayfish? Here are two easy preparation methods:
1. Crayfish Boil
-
In a large pot, bring water, lemon slices, garlic, and Cajun seasoning to a boil.
-
Once boiling, add live crayfish and cook for 2-3 minutes until bright orange.
-
Drain crayfish and dump onto a newspaper-lined table for easy eating.
-
Peel crayfish tails and claws to access the savory meat.
2. Steamed Crayfish
-
Fill a pot with an inch of water and bring to a boil.
-
Add crayfish to a metal steaming basket and lower into the pot.
-
Steam crayfish for 4-5 minutes until opaque and cooked through.
-
Remove crayfish and serve with melted butter.
Either boiling or steaming coaxes out crayfish’s tender, mildly sweet flavor – an economical alternative to boiled lobster!
Savor The Shellfish Flavors
While not identical, crayfish offer the most similar taste and texture to lobster of any shellfish. Their shared crustacean roots shine through in a mildly briny sweetness when cooked.
Next time lobster is out of your budget, try swapping in a crayfish boil or steamer. Your wallet and tastebuds will thank you!
So embrace the chance to savor shellfish far from the ocean. Treat yourself to delectable crayfish – a little lobster love for less.
Catfish & Shrimp Feast (3 course meal) Chicken & Sausage Gumbo, Salad, (6) fried Shrimp, Catfish Strips, fries or rings and hushpuppies $299
Monday – Friday 11:00 am – 3:00 pm
What Does Crawfish Taste Like?
Even though crawfish is usually thought of as seafood, it doesn’t have a strong flavor like many other seafood dishes. Compared to crab, crawfish do have a stronger flavor and are usually much meatier. A lot of people say that crawfish tastes like a mix of shrimp and crab because it’s slightly salty, slightly sweet, and slightly mineral. The taste of crawfish ultimately depends on which parts you are eating and how it’s been prepared.
The edible parts of this sea creature include the claws, tails, legs, tomalley, roe, and outer shell. Most people think that the claws, legs, and tails are the best parts of a crawfish because they have the most meat. The claws are mild and sweet, and they feel smooth. The tails, on the other hand, are a bit rougher and harder to chew. Despite the heartiness of the tails, a quarter pound of them contains just 82 calories.
There are many ways to cook crawfish tail. People often steam or boil them, just like they do with lobster. You can also grill, pan sear, broil, or bake them. Even though crawfish tails taste great on their own, they are even better in Cajun seafood recipes that use lots of tasty spices and ingredients.
The next time you’re poring over the menu at Crazy Alan’s Swamp Shack, consider the well-loved crawfish. You might just discover your new favorite seafood.
- Sun-Thurs 11:00AM – 9:00PM
- Fri-Sat 11:00AM – 10:00PM
Maine Lobster Vs. Crawfish Taste Testing! (Which is Better?)
What does crayfish taste like?
Crayfish meat has a similar taste to lobster. They both have a savory, appetizing flavor. Crayfish can be prepared by boiling or steaming them. Only a small part of the crayfish is edible, as with all edible crustaceans. They can be added to dishes such as soups, etouffee, bisques, or jambalaya. Crayfish are usually prepared with Cajun seasoning.
Are crayfish and lobster related?
Crayfish and lobster are both members of the crustacean family, but they are not closely related. Crayfish are more closely related to shrimp and prawns, while lobsters are more closely related to crabs. What are the different species of crayfish and lobster?
What is the difference between crayfish and lobster?
Crayfish and lobsters are close relatives. That’s why they look so much alike, and people seem to confuse the two. They may taste the same when cooked and look the same while alive, but several differences set them apart. Let’s check out the difference between both! Crayfish and lobsters may look identical to the untrained eye.
Can crayfish be substituted for lobster?
Crayfish can be substituted for lobster in many recipes, but there are some differences in flavor and texture. Because crayfish meat is slightly more earthy in flavor and has a slightly firmer texture, it may not be the best choice for dishes that rely on the delicate sweetness and tenderness of lobster meat.