You can buy stone crabs fresh or frozen, so you can keep them until you’re ready to serve them. It’s important to know how to tell if stone crab claws are cooked no matter where you buy them so you can cook them safely for your family or guests. Learn how to tell if a crab is done and how that can change the way you cook stone crab claws.
Stone crab claws are a delicious delicacy, especially popular along the East and Gulf coasts of the United States. Their rich, sweet flavor and tender meat make them a special treat. However, cooking stone crab claws properly is important to bring out their best texture and taste.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll walk through the basics of stone crab claws, and provide simple, foolproof methods to cook them at home. Whether you want to boil, steam, or bake your claws, we have pro tips to help you make these decadent crustaceans into a mouthwatering meal.
Stone crabs are a species of crab that live in warm ocean waters. Their claws are harvested for food while the crab itself is returned alive to the ocean. This ensures a sustainable fishery, since the crabs can regenerate their claws.
Only one claw is taken from each crab The claws regenerate in about 18 months, and can be re-harvested So enjoying stone crab claws actually helps conserve the crab population!
Stone crab season runs from October 15 to May 15. The claws are served chilled, and the meat is renowned for its firm yet tender texture and sweet, briny flavor. Many aficionados consider stone crab to be the most succulent and delicious crab meat of all.
Choosing Stone Crab Claws
When buying stone crab claws, look for claws labeled “Large” or “Jumbo”. Larger claws will have more meat. The meat should have a white or pale pink tint. Reddish meat indicates undercooking.
Tap the claw lightly It should feel firm and heavy for its size, not hollow. Soft or lightweight claws won’t have a lot of meat
Examine the shell. It should be an even tan color, not cracked or damaged. Damaged shells indicate mishandling.
Avoid claws with dark black tips. This means the claw was harvested too late in the season. The meat will be stringy and tasteless.
Finally, give the claw a sniff. Fresh, healthy stone crab has almost no odor. Rancid or ammonia scents mean the meat has spoiled.
How to Cook Stone Crab Claws
Stone crab claws can be prepared by boiling, steaming, or baking. Each method has its pros and cons. Here’s an overview:
-
Boiling cooks the claws quickly, and allows you to add seasoning to the water. However, some subtler flavors can be lost.
-
Steaming is slower, but preserves more of the natural flavor. The claws don’t absorb additional seasoning.
-
Baking gives great flavor, but takes a bit more time. Baking also tends to dry out the meat.
No matter which cooking method you choose, proper handling is important. Cook the claws gently to avoid making the meat rubbery. Don’t discard the shells until serving time, as the shells insulate the meat during cooking.
Now let’s look at how to prepare delicious stone crab claws using each technique.
Boiling Stone Crab Claws
Boiling is a quick and easy way to cook multiple claws at once. Add seasonings to the water to infuse more flavor.
What You’ll Need:
- Raw stone crab claws, enough for 4 servings
- Large pot
- Colander or slotted spoon
- Seasonings of your choice (Old Bay, lemon pepper, etc.)
Instructions
-
Fill a large pot about halfway with water. Add 1-2 tablespoons of seasoning per quart of water, to taste. Bring to a boil over high heat.
-
Gently lower the claws into the boiling water. Cook for 3-5 minutes only. Overcooking will make the meat tough.
-
Remove the claws with a colander or slotted spoon. Allow to cool slightly before cracking and eating.
-
To serve, use a mallet or claw cracker to break the shells. Remove pieces of sweet crab meat with a small fork.
Steaming Stone Crab Claws
Steaming is slower than boiling, but seals in moisture and natural flavors. The process is simple with a steamer basket.
What You’ll Need:
- Raw stone crab claws, enough for 4 servings
- Large pot with tight-fitting lid
- Steamer basket
Instructions:
-
Fill pot with 2-3 inches of water. Bring to a rolling boil over high heat.
-
Place steamer basket in pot. Make sure it sits above the water line.
-
Arrange claws in a single layer in the basket. Cover pot tightly.
-
Steam for 4-5 minutes only. Overcooking makes meat rubbery.
-
Use tongs to transfer claws to a plate. Allow to cool slightly before serving.
-
Crack shells with mallet or claw cracker. Pull out tender chunks of meat with a small fork.
Baking Stone Crab Claws
Baking claws in the oven gives great results. Just watch the cooking time closely to prevent drying out.
What You’ll Need:
- Raw stone crab claws, enough for 4 servings
- Rimmed baking sheet
- Aluminum foil
Instructions:
-
Preheat oven to 375°F. Line baking sheet with foil for easy cleanup.
-
Arrange claws on sheet in a single layer. Make sure they don’t overlap.
-
Bake for 8-10 minutes only. Check frequently to avoid overbaking.
-
Use a mallet or claw cracker to break shells. Be careful, as claws will be hot initially.
-
Pull meat out in chunks with a small fork. Enjoy immediately for maximum tenderness.
Serving Suggestions for Stone Crab Claws
Stone crab claws taste fantastic on their own. But you can also enhance them with dipping sauces and creative presentations.
Here are some serving ideas to delight your guests:
- Chilled claws served with lemon wedges and drawn butter
- Claw meat placed back in shells for a dramatic look
- Meat mixed with aioli or remoulade sauce for dipping
- Piled atop a classic crab louis salad
- Served in lettuce wrap “tacos” with mango salsa
- Mixed with creamy pasta in a decadent crab alfredo
- Scattered across avocado toast points for an appetizer
- Topped with a drizzle of olive oil and fresh dill
However you choose to serve them, stone crab claws are sure to be the star of any meal! Follow these tips for flawlessly cooked claws every time.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cooking Stone Crabs
How can I tell when the claws are fully cooked?
Check that the shell has turned bright red/orange. The meat should be opaque and flake easily with a fork. Discard any parts that are still translucent.
What’s the best way to reheat leftover claws?
Place claws in a 350°F oven for 5-7 minutes just until heated through. Microwaving makes the meat rubbery.
Can I freeze extra stone crab claws for later?
Yes, freeze uncooked claws for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge before cooking. Don’t refreeze previously cooked claws.
What’s the most efficient way to get the meat out of the shells?
Use claw crackers or kitchen shears to snip down the length of each leg. Then simply lift out the whole chunk of meat.
Are the dark tips on the claws safe to eat?
No, trim off and discard the dark cartilage at the end. Only eat the sweet white and light pink meat.
With these expert tips, you’ll be enjoying restaurant-quality stone crab claws in your own home. Impress your guests with some fresh-cooked claws paired with a creamy dip or zesty salsa. The sweet, succulent meat is a real delicacy that’s fun to pick out from the shell. So get cracking with these easy preparation methods for stone crab claw perfection!
Steaming / Boiling Stone Crabs
To steam or boil your stone crabs, youll need a pot, two cups of water, and a colander. Bring the water to a boil and place the Florida stone crab claws into the pot. You dont even need to season them. Cover the pot and let them cook for about 10 minutes. When the room starts to smell like cooked crab meat, take them out of the water and serve right away. Dont cook any longer than necessary, or your crab meat will overcook, becoming chewy and tough.
The Crab Shell Inspection Test: Check the Outside
If youre curious whether your stone crabs have been cooked, you simply check the outside of the shell. Luckily, you wont need to crack it to examine the meat inside. Fully cooked stone crabs have shells that are bright red or orange. If yours is green or brown, you can assume it has not been cooked.