We can’t think of many cases where we would not be able to finish our cooked lobster. But if you made too much for a party and don’t want your lobsters to go to waste, you could save them as leftovers and reheat them another day.
It’s best to reheat lobsters in a way that doesn’t change their taste or texture, just like with most other foods. This helpful guide will show you how to do that.
As a seafood lover, I always order lobster whenever I see it on a restaurant menu. That sweet, succulent meat dipped in melted lemon butter is simply to die for! However, I don’t always finish my lobster in one sitting. When bringing home leftovers, reheating pre-cooked lobster properly is key to preserving texture and flavor.
In my trials of reheating leftover lobster I found keeping it in the shell is best. The shell helps lock in the natural juices and seasonings. When reheated this way the meat doesn’t dry out or become rubbery.
In this article I’ll share how to reheat cooked lobster in the shell using simple methods anyone can do at home. I’ll also explain why reheating in the shell beats other methods for getting the best results. Let’s crack into it!
Why Reheating Lobster in the Shell Is Best
Here are some of the top reasons reheating cooked lobster in the shell reigns supreme:
-
Preserves moisture and texture – The shell creates a protective barrier to keep lobster meat tender.
-
Locks in seasoning flavors – Any spices, lemon, or butter soak into the meat and stay there.
-
Adds extra taste – Cooking juices in the shell infuse more flavor.
-
Maintains shape – The shell keeps lobster meat from falling apart when reheating.
-
Easy cleanup – No need to worry about lobster meat sticking to pans.
While methods like grilling, sautéing, or microwaving de-shelled lobster work, I find keeping it in the original shell is foolproof.
How to Reheat Lobster in the Shell
When reheating cooked lobster in the shell, the oven is your best bet for evenly heating and maximum flavor. Here’s a simple oven reheating method:
Step 1: Preheat oven to 350°F.
Step 2: Place lobster shells directly on a baking sheet or oven-safe dish.
Step 3: Cover shells loosely with aluminum foil.
Step 4: Heat in oven for 10-15 minutes until warmed through.
Step 5: Check internal temperature with a meat thermometer to ensure it reaches 165°F.
Step 6: Serve immediately and enjoy!
Be careful not to overcook the reheated lobster or it could become rubbery. Keeping it in the shell prevents this.
This oven method allows the lobster to heat gradually all over, preserving its texture beautifully. The foil cover locks in moisture released from the shell.
Other Tips for Reheating Lobster in Shell
To get the most flavor and enjoyment from reheated lobster in the shell, keep these additional tips in mind:
-
Add a dash of butter or lemon juice in the shell before reheating for extra flavor.
-
Microwave reheating works in a pinch. Heat shells 1-2 minutes max.
-
Drizzle with melted butter or lemon aioli sauce after reheating.
-
Serve with a crusty bread for dipping juices and butter in the shell.
-
Garnish with fresh parsley or lemon wedges.
-
Don’t re-season before reheating as residual spices will reactivate.
-
Consume reheated lobster within 3-4 days for best quality.
Follow these best practices for reheating lobster in the shell and you’ll be rewarded with tender, juicy meat that tastes freshly cooked!
Common Mistakes to Avoid
While reheating lobster in the shell is quite simple, there are some common pitfalls to watch out for:
-
Overcooking – This causes the meat to toughen and dry out.
-
Undercooking – Not heating it enough risks unsafe bacteria growth.
-
No temperature check – Use a meat thermometer to verify doneness.
-
Removing meat from shell – The shell seals in flavor, moisture and shape.
-
Adding too much liquid – A splash of butter or broth is enough in the shell.
As long as you follow the proper oven reheating steps, avoid these mistakes, and remember to keep it in the shell, your leftovers will taste fabulous.
Enjoy Restaurant-Quality Lobster at Home
Being able to revive leftover lobster so it tastes as scrumptious as the original restaurant meal is an invaluable skill. Now that you know how easy and effective reheating cooked lobster in the shell is, you can indulge more often.
Next time you order lobster out, go ahead and get your money’s worth. Take the leftovers home and reuse the shells like nature intended to preserve that fresh, juicy texture and flavor burst.
For fellow lobster fans, what’s your favorite go-to dipping sauce or garnish? I’d love to hear your reheating tips and tricks in the comments!
How to Reheat Lobster Safely in the Microwave
Putting food back in the microwave can be safe for most foods, but you need to make sure you heat them to the right temperature. When food gets cold spots, bacteria can grow that are bad for you and can later make you sick or upset your stomach. Lobster is no exception, so learning how to reheat lobster safely in the microwave is important.
This is the best way to learn how to reheat lobster in its shell so that the flavor and texture stay the same:
- Place lobsters on a plate that can go in the microwave. Wrap them in damp paper towels.
- Place your microwave on its “High” setting.
- Warm the lobster for one to two minutes, then use a digital meat thermometer to check the temperature of the meat. It should reach at least 140-degrees.
Also, you can heat up lobster meat that isn’t in its shell. It might only need 30 seconds to a minute. Again, be sure to check its temperature with a thermometer before eating!.
How to Reheat Lobster Tail in the Oven
Although microwaving is quick and convenient, we recommend using the oven to reheat lobster if you have time. You have to spend a little more time on it, but it works better and can keep the flavors and textures of your lobster, making you feel like you’re eating the original dish all over again.
- Preheat the oven to 350-degrees Fahrenheit.
- Clams or tails that have been shelled should be wrapped in aluminum foil and a little butter should be spread over the meat.
- Line up the lobsters and put them on a baking sheet. Bake for five to ten minutes.
- Take the lobster out of the oven and use a thermometer to make sure it’s at least 140 degrees.
You can also create small foil packets for lobster meat not in its shell. Add some butter and seasonings to keep it tasting fresh!.
How to Reheat Cooked Lobster Tails : Cooking Tips & Recipes
How do you reheat frozen lobster?
To reheat frozen lobster or even refrigerated lobster, the key is to ensure it’s reheated over a gentle heat, which is why the oven is the best choice here. Turn on the oven and preheat it to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Remove the lobster from its shell.
Can You reheat lobster meat outside the shell?
You can reheat lobster meat outside of its shell, too, but it may only need about 30 seconds to a minute. Again, be sure to check its temperature with a thermometer before eating! Although microwaving is quick and convenient, we recommend using the oven to reheat lobster if you have time.
How do you reheat lobsters in a crock pot?
1. Bring the water in the pot to a boil over medium heat. 2. Once the water is boiling, carefully place your prepared lobsters onto the steaming rack inside the pot. If reheating multiple lobsters, make sure they are arranged in a single layer without overcrowding. 3.
How do you reheat lobster tail?
Place the seasoned meat directly on the grill. Position it on the grill with the shell side facing down and avoid flipping it. Allow the grill to work its magic, heating the lobster until it’s thoroughly warmed through. When dealing with leftover lobster tail, reheat it in the oven or toaster oven.