How Much Does a Live Lobster Cost? A Closer Look at Live Lobster Prices

Lobster is considered a luxurious decadent seafood delicacy. With its sweet succulent meat and unique texture, it’s no wonder why lobster dishes command such high prices on restaurant menus. But for those wanting to indulge in fresh lobster in the comfort of their own home, how much does a live lobster actually cost?

Live Lobster Prices Vary Based on Size

One of the biggest factors determining the cost of a live lobster is the size Lobsters are sold by the pound, with prices fluctuating based on the exact weight Generally, the larger the lobster, the pricier it will be.

Here’s an overview of estimated price ranges for different live lobster sizes:

• 1.25 pound lobster: $46 – $49
• 1.5 pound lobster: $58 – $59
• 2 pound lobster: $78 – $99
• 3 pound lobster: $94 – $109
• 5-6 pound “giant” lobster: $179 – $199

So if you’re looking for a smaller lobster for a single serving, expect to pay around $50 But for an impressive giant lobster to serve a crowd, prices can approach $200

Buying Multiple Lobsters Can Lower Costs

One money-saving tip when buying live lobster is to order multiple at once. Many seafood retailers offer discounted pricing for bulk lobster orders.

For example, at Lobster Anywhere, the per-lobster price drops from $58 down to $52 when ordering 4 x 1.5 pound lobsters. And at Maine Lobster Now, the per-lobster cost decreases from $99 to $89 when buying 4 x 2 pound lobsters.

So if hosting a lobster dinner party, take advantage of these quantity discounts to save.

Live vs Frozen Makes a Price Difference

In addition to size, the form of the lobster also impacts cost. Live lobsters that are shipped overnight from the coast will be more expensive than frozen lobster tails or meat. That’s because:

• Special packing and overnight shipping fees are required for live seafood
• More handling and logistics involved for live products
• Supply and demand – live is perceived as fresher

For instance, a frozen 16-20 ounce lobster tail runs about $80. But a similar weight live 2 pound lobster may cost up to $100.

Online Prices vs Grocery Stores

Ordering live lobster online through seafood retailers will generally be cheaper than buying at your local grocery store. That’s because online seafood companies:

• Work directly with lobster fishermen
• Operate high volume fulfillment centers
• Specialize in live seafood shipping logistics

This allows them to offer premium quality live lobsters, shipped overnight at lower prices than lobsters sitting in tanks at the supermarket.

Geographic Location Makes a Difference

Where you’re located in relation to the lobster source makes a difference in live lobster pricing. Lobsters sourced from the cold waters of New England and Maine are highly sought after.

So those on the West Coast may pay $10-$15 more per lobster for overnight shipping from Maine than customers located in New York.

Being closer to the lobster supply source equates to lower transportation costs and therefore lower prices.

Seasonality Impacts Costs Too

Lobster prices fluctuate throughout the year with supply and demand. Late spring through early fall is peak lobster season with the highest catches. Prices are generally lowest during this bountiful time.

Whereas in the colder winter months, lobster supplies are lower. Strong holiday demand for indulgent seafood also drives live lobster prices higher from November through January.

How to Get the Best Deal on Live Lobster

To get the best value when buying live lobster, here are some tips:

• Buy in bulk quantities if possible
• Order lobster online instead of at the grocery store
• Be flexible on lobster weight – allow a range like 1.25-1.5 pounds
• Compare prices between a few different seafood retailers
• Purchase live lobster during peak summer season if you can

At the end of the day, live lobster is a premium product. So expect to pay a premium price. But being a savvy shopper, ordering during peak season, and buying bulk can help lower the costs on this luxurious seafood delicacy.

Is it Worth Paying More for Live Lobster?

While live lobster does come at a higher price, many feel it’s worth paying extra to enjoy lobster at its absolute freshest and finest. There’s just no substitute for savoring tender, juicy meat straight from a just-caught, still kicking lobster.

The unbeatable sweet flavor and delicate texture is why lobster lovers are willing to shell out (pun intended) the higher costs associated with live lobster. The experience of cooking a live lobster at home and sharing with family is for many worth the price.

So while lobster prices may seem steep compared to other seafood, once you indulge in the delectable meat, you’ll quickly realize why people have been willing to pay a premium for live lobster for centuries. Just be sure to take advantage of seafood discounts and order during peak season to get the very best deal!