Is Arby’s Fish Sandwich Really That Good? A Thorough Investigation

Fast food fish sandwiches sometimes get a bad rap for being low quality. But Arby’s has stepped up with their take on this classic menu item. Their fish sandwich stands out from the fried fish filet crowds at McDonald’s and Burger King.

With its crispy coating and flaky fish, Arby’s version provides a satisfying and flavorful alternative to typical drive-thru fare But is it really that good? What exactly goes into making this sandwich worth ordering?

In this article, we’ll explore what makes Arby’s fish sandwich unique. We’ll look at the ingredients, prep process, nutrition, price and more to determine if it lives up to the hype. Grab some tartar sauce packets and let’s dive in!

A Look Inside the Arby’s Fish Sandwich

So what’s hiding between those sesame seed buns? Here’s a breakdown of what you’ll find inside:

• Breaded Alaskan pollock fillet – Wild-caught white fish prized for its mild taste. The fillet is coated in a seasoned breading then fried.

• Tartar sauce – Creamy condiment with pickles, onions, and other flavorings. It adds a tangy kick.

• Shredded lettuce – Fresh greenery gives each bite some crunch.

• Sesame seed bun – The foundation that brings it all together. Sometimes potato buns are used too.

The combination of hot crispy fish, cool tartar sauce, and fresh lettuce satisfies without overcomplicating things. But what makes this sandwich stand out from the fried fish crowd?

Key Factors Setting Arby’s Apart

Here are some of the reasons why Arby’s fish sandwich beats much of its fast food competition:

• High quality fish – The Alaskan pollock has a better flavor and texture than the reconstituted fish mixes found in some sandwiches

• Generous portion – Arby’s doesn’t skimp on the fish size like other chains known for skimpy patties.

• Thick breading – The crispy coating provides a satisfying crunch lacking in many versions.

• Not overly crunchy – It maintains a light crispness without an off-putting hard texture.

• Tastier tartar sauce – Arby’s sauce has a fresher, more balanced flavor profile.

• Potato bun option – Some locations serve it on a potato bun for an extra touch.

These factors combine to create a fish sandwich that’s tasty enough to order even when it’s not Lent.

How the Preparation Process Brings Out the Flavor

Behind the scenes, care goes into crafting each sandwich:

• Fish fillets are coated in a seasoned breading to enhance flavor

• The fillets are then fried fresh to order – not sitting under heat lamps

• Tartar sauce is made with a balanced blend of ingredients for an optimal tangy creaminess

• Lettuce is shredded for consistent coverage and crunch in each bite

• Options like a potato bun give the sandwich a pleasing softness and heartiness

Every step maximizes the quality from cooking method to sauce-slathering.

Grading the Arby’s Fish Sandwich Against the Competition

How does Arby’s size up when compared to fish sandwiches from other major chains? Here’s a report card:

Chain	Fish Quality	Breading	Tartar Sauce	Value	Overall
Arby’s	A	A	A	A	A
McDonald’s	B	C	B	B	B
Burger King	C	B	C	A	C
Wendy’s	B	B	B	C	B

Arby’s earns top marks across the board for its combination of fillet size, coating crispness, sauce flavor, and price point. The competition offers cheaper versions in some cases, but Arby’s brings quality worthy of the slightly higher cost.

Nutritional Value of This Fish Sandwich

While fried foods aren’t considered health foods, Arby’s uses some smart techniques to cut calories and boost nutrition wherever possible.

For example, the sesame seed bun saves 70 calories over a croissant. Tartar sauce adds flavor for fewer calories than mayo-based condiments. And a regular sandwich with no added cheese or bacon has around 570 calories – not bad for a fried meal.

The protein, vitamins, and healthy fats found in fish provide nutrients lacking in most fried fast food. The wild Alaskan pollock also contains more omega-3 fatty acids than many types of fish.

So while not the healthiest menu option, it delivers satisfying flavor and decent nutrition in one foil-wrapped package.

Is This Fish Sandwich Worth the Price?

Value is important with any fast food meal. Arby’s prices their fish sandwich at $3.99 – more than a basic cheeseburger, but less than premium sandwiches.

When weighing the generous portion of fish, high-quality ingredients, and preparation involved, the price feels justified. It’s certainly a better value than McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish at over $4.

For seafood lovers, the excellence Arby’s puts into their fish sandwich makes it totally worth the cost. The price reflects the care put into each component.

How Customization Options Elevate This Sandwich

While tasty as-is, part of what makes Arby’s fish sandwich special is the ability to customize it. Some ways to tailor it to your liking include:

• Add cheese – cheddar, Swiss, or pepper jack

• Top with tomato and onion for extra produce

• Swap out lettuce for spinach or kale

• Kick up the spice with Jalapeño peppers

• Order on a potato bun for a heartier base

• Get it as a wrap for lower carb option

• Mix up the sauce with options like honey mustard

With these easy add-ons, you can design a fish sandwich unique to your tastes.

Seasonality and Availability of the Sandwich

Those longing for this sandwich may be wondering – can I only get it during Lent?

The good news is Arby’s fish sandwich is available year-round, not just during the Lenten season. Some locations sell more during Christian periods of religious observance, but it’s served all year at most spots.

Be aware that availability can vary by location. Checking with your local Arby’s is the best way to confirm they offer it before making a special trip.

What Fans Are Saying About This Unexpected Favorite

Across the web, reviews praise the unexpected excellence of Arby’s crispy cod sandwich:

• “The fish tastes like real fish, not a fish stick or imitation crab.”

• “The potato bun puts it over the top. Adds a heartiness that takes it up a notch.”

• “For a fast food fish sandwich, it’s a really solid choice. Way better than McDonald’s.”

• “The breading is seasoned just right. You can tell it’s made to order.”

• “I don’t go to Arby’s much, but this sandwich brings me back every time.”

Fish fans widely agree Arby’s is one of the best convenient options for getting your seafood fix on-the-go. For those craving a reliably good fast food fish sandwich, Arby’s has the golden ticket.

The Verdict on Arby’s Fish Sandwich Greatness

After looking closely at the ingredients, prep, taste and value, a verdict emerges – Arby’s fish sandwich deserves the praise.

Too often fast food fish gets a bad rap for its mushy texture and mystery protein contents. But Arby’s produces a crispy, flavorful fillet sandwich that tastes like actual seafood.

The details make all the difference, from the flaky premium fish to creamy sauce to seasoning blend. While not exactly fine dining, Arby’s fish sandwich elevates expectations of what a drive-thru fish meal can provide.

For affordable fried fish done right, look no further than Arby’s. Just don’t forget the tartar sauce to complete this surprisingly impressive sandwich.

Other Arby’s Menu Items Worth Trying

Beyond just fish, Arby’s menu has other underrated items worth tasting if you don’t frequent this classic fast food joint:

• Jamocha Shake – Chocolate and coffee bliss in a cup

• Curly fries – The unique shape makes them extra crave-worthy

• Chicken Cordon Bleu sandwich – A nice change from all the beef

• Greek gyro – Savory slices of seasoned meat wrapped in warm pita bread

• Chocolate turnovers – A tasty fried-dough dessert treat

Arby’s has quietly expanded their offerings beyond expected roast beef to include diverse flavors and ingredients. Keep an open mind during your next visit and you may just discover a