Gefilte fish—the quintessential Jewish fish dish made from poached balls or loaves of ground, deboned fish—is a cuisine staple during Passover and other Jewish holidays But for people with gluten sensitivity or celiac disease, this tradition-steeped meal may seem off limits.
After all most traditional recipes call for matzo meal, which contains wheat and gluten. So is it possible to enjoy gefilte fish while maintaining a gluten-free diet?
The short answer is yes—with some modifications, you can absolutely make and enjoy delicious gluten-free gefilte fish for your holiday meals. Read on for a complete guide to understanding gefilte fish and gluten, plus tips for modifying recipes and finding gluten-free options.
A Brief History of Gefilte Fish
Gefilte fish has been an important part of Jewish cuisine for centuries. The dish likely originated in Germany during the Middle Ages as a creative way to stretch expensive fish into a hearty meal.
The earliest known recipe dates back to the 13th century cookbook “Kuchbüchlein für israelitische Frauen” by Bertha Kramer. The name “gefilte fish” comes from the Yiddish word “gefilte,” meaning “stuffed.”
Traditionally, gefilte fish was made by grinding different types of fish along with eggs, onion, and matzo meal into a dough-like consistency. Cooks would then shape the mixture into balls or loaf shapes before poaching and serving.
Over the years, recipes evolved as Jewish communities migrated around the world. European recipes often blended carp and pike, while North African Jews used haddock and cod. American variations introduced new flavors like sugar and ginger.
No matter how it’s prepared, gefilte fish remains a nostalgic staple that conjures up memories of family gatherings and links modern Jews to their ancestral roots.
Understanding Gluten in Gefilte Fish Recipes
So why is gluten an issue when it comes to enjoying gefilte fish?
Most traditional recipes call for matzo meal as one of the key binding ingredients. Matzo is an unleavened flatbread that’s eaten during Passover to commemorate the Jews’ exodus from Egypt. Since it’s made from wheat, matzo contains gluten.
By extension, matzo meal contains gluten as well. A typical gefilte fish recipe uses anywhere from 1⁄4 to 1 cup of matzo meal combined with white fish like pike, trout, or halibut.
For people with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity, consuming gefilte fish made in the traditional way could trigger uncomfortable symptoms like bloating, abdominal pain, and fatigue. In cases of celiac disease, it could even lead to intestinal damage over time.
Thankfully, it’s entirely possible to adapt gefilte fish recipes to be gluten-free without sacrificing taste or texture.
Tips for Making Gluten-Free Gefilte Fish
If you follow a strict gluten-free diet, don’t resign yourself to missing out on gefilte fish during the holidays. With a few simple modifications, you can whip up a delicious gluten-free version at home.
Here are some tips:
-
Substitute matzo meal with gluten-free flours or starches. Almond flour, coconut flour, potato starch, and tapioca flour all make excellent matzo meal replacements. You may need to experiment with different combinations to get the right consistency.
-
Use gluten-free breadcrumbs or matzo. Look for gluten-free panko or homemade breadcrumbs. You can make your own by pulsing gluten-free bread or matzo in a food processor.
-
Bind with eggs and/or potatoes. Eggs help bind and hold the fish mixture together. For extra stability, incorporate boiled and mashed potatoes.
-
Add xanthan gum. About 1/2 teaspoon of xanthan gum per 1 pound of fish mixture can help recreate the elastic texture provided by gluten.
-
Adjust cooking techniques. Chilling the mixed fish overnight helps it hold its shape better when cooking. Poaching in broth rather than boiling in water can also help.
-
Enhance flavor. Get creative with gluten-free flavor boosters like fresh herbs, lemon, carrot, onions, horseradish, or spices like nutmeg and paprika.
Buying Gluten-Free Gefilte Fish
If preparing homemade gefilte fish from scratch seems too daunting, store-bought varieties offer a convenient shortcut. More manufacturers are producing gluten-free gefilte fish to meet growing demand:
-
Mrs. Adler’s Gefilte Fish – This leading brand offers gluten-free gefilte fish balls and loaves made with potato starch instead of matzo meal. Look for them in the kosher frozen food aisle.
-
Kohn’s Kosher Gefilte Fish – Kohn’s makes gluten-free gefilte fish loaf and patties using water and potato starch as binders. They’re Certified Gluten-Free.
-
A&B Famous Gefilte Fish – A&B provides gluten-free gefilte fish balls, loaves, and logs Seasonings like carrot, onion, and sweet beet flavor the fish.
-
Organic Gluten Free Gefilte Fish by Natural Noodles – Available for delivery online, this variety uses tamari matzo and potato starch for gluten-free binding.
Keep in mind that gefilte fish products are often produced in facilities that also process wheat foods. Be sure to check labels closely and look for certified gluten-free when possible.
Ordering Gluten-Free Gefilte Fish at Restaurants
Ordering gefilte fish at a kosher deli or restaurant has some additional considerations. Since kitchens are using shared prep areas and cookware, cross-contamination is a risk.
To stay safe when eating out:
-
Ask explicitly about how the gefilte fish is prepared and which ingredients are used.
-
Request that it’s made with a clean set of cookware and utensils.
-
Ask if there’s a designated gluten-free prep area.
-
Check that the broth it’s poached in doesn’t contain wheat.
-
Look for menu items marked “gluten-free” or ask your server for help identifying options.
-
Be aware that factors like shared fryers or cookware could still introduce trace gluten.
The Takeaway: Enjoy Your Traditions Gluten-Free
Passover and other Jewish holidays center around cherished food traditions—but celiac disease and gluten intolerance don’t have to mean missing out. With some easy ingredient swaps and recipe adjustments, you can still enjoy delicious gluten-free gefilte fish as part of your celebrations.
Look for gluten-free recipes online, modify traditional family recipes, or seek out reputable store-bought options to serve at your next meal. And if cooking from scratch sounds daunting, don’t hesitate to order gefilte fish carefully when dining out.
Above all, speak up about your dietary needs—friends and family will happily make accommodations so you can continue honoring timeless food traditions, gluten-free style!
