One excellent method to cook large birds, like turkeys, without drying them out and to give the meat a deep flavor is by smoking them.
Obviously, the first thing you have to decide when smoking a turkey is what kind of turkey you want to use. But closely behind are the kind of wood you’ll be using and the flavor you wish it to impart.
Personally, we like the rich color and sweet-smoky flavor of cherry wood with a hint of hickory.
However, the kind of wood you choose will rely on your tastes, so we’ll give you all of your options rather than imposing our opinion on the best one.
Q: Can I use hickory wood to smoke my Thanksgiving turkey?
A: Definitely! Hickory is a traditional option for smoking turkey because it has a strong, smokey flavor that many people find enticing. But be careful when using it—its potent flavor can quickly overpower the delicate flavor of turkey.
Here’s what you need to know about using hickory for smoking turkey:
Pros:
- Rich, smoky flavor: Hickory is known for its intense, smoky flavor that adds depth and complexity to the taste of the turkey.
- Beautiful color: Hickory smoke imparts a beautiful golden brown color to the turkey skin, making it visually appealing.
- Versatility: Hickory pairs well with a variety of seasonings and rubs, allowing you to customize the flavor profile to your liking.
Cons:
- Strong flavor: Hickory can easily overpower the taste of turkey, especially if used in large quantities or for extended smoking times.
- Bitterness: If not used carefully, hickory can impart a bitter taste to the turkey.
- Not for everyone: Some people find the strong smoky flavor of hickory to be too overpowering.
Tips for using hickory with turkey:
- Use sparingly: Start with a small amount of hickory wood, and gradually add more if desired.
- Combine with milder woods: Mix hickory with milder woods like apple or cherry to balance the smoky flavor.
- Monitor the smoke time: Don’t smoke the turkey for too long, as this can lead to bitterness.
- Consider the taste preferences of your guests: If you’re unsure about how much hickory to use, err on the side of caution and start with a smaller amount.
Alternatives to hickory:
- Apple: Offers a sweet and fruity flavor that complements turkey well.
- Cherry: Provides a mild, sweet smoke with a hint of almond.
- Maple: Adds a subtle sweetness and a beautiful golden color.
- Oak: Offers a more neutral smoke flavor that allows the natural taste of the turkey to shine through.
Ultimately, the best wood for smoking turkey is a matter of personal preference. Experiment with different woods and find what you like best!
Additional resources:
- Reddit discussion on preferred wood for smoking turkey: https://www.reddit.com/r/BBQ/comments/5dys2b/what_is_your_preferred_wood_for_smoking_turkey/
- Information on different types of smoking woods: https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/hickory-turkey.84351/
Happy smoking!
Are wood chips or wood pellets better for smoking turkey?
Choosing wood chips or pellets, or even logs or chunks, comes down to what smoker you have.
As one might expect, pellets work best in a pellet smoker, but they also work perfectly in an electric smoker—as long as the pellets stay inside the wood tray and don’t fall through the holes.
Electric and charcoal smokers usually use wood chips, but offset smokers, with their larger firebox, use larger wood chunks or logs.
It’s generally best to select the appropriate wood size for your smoker, even though wood chips and wood pellets aren’t that different from one another.
Q: Is mesquite bad for smoking turkey?
A: Mesquite is a very strongly flavored wood that can easily overwhelm the taste of the turkey. We recommend you keep it for more robust BBQ meats and stick to lighter woods for smoking turkey.
How To Smoke A Turkey On An ‘Ole Hickory
FAQ
What’s the best wood to smoke a turkey with?
Is hickory smoke good for turkey?
What meats are best to smoke with hickory?
What is the best pellet flavor for turkey?