The Fishy Truth About Worcestershire Sauce
Worcestershire sauce is a pantry staple in many homes. Its tangy, umami flavor adds depth and savoriness to everything from steaks to stir fries. But if you take a close look at the ingredients list on a bottle of Lea & Perrins, you’ll spot something that may surprise you – anchovies.
So is there really fish in Worcestershire sauce? Let’s dig into the facts.
A Brief History of Worcestershire Sauce
To understand the fishy component, we need to go back in time. Worcestershire sauce originated in England during the early 1800s. According to legend, Lord Sandys, the governor of Bengal, brought a recipe back after traveling in India. He asked two chemists, John Lea and William Perrins, to try to recreate it.
Their first attempts failed dismally. The mixture fermented for years in a stone cellar, abandoned and forgotten. When they finally tasted it again, the aged sauce was delicious. Lea & Perrins Worcestershire Sauce was born.
Traditional Ingredients in Worcestershire Sauce
So what exactly gives Worcestershire sauce its unique tang? These are some of the key ingredients that traditionally go into the condiment:
-
Anchovies – These tiny, oily fish provide savory umami flavor through compounds like glutamate. They’re essential to the sauce.
-
Tamarind – Dried tamarind pulp adds both sweet and sour notes. It provides acidity and fruity depth.
-
Onions and garlic – Aromatics like onions and garlic offer pungent, savory flavor. They balance the acidity
-
Molasses – Dark molasses contributes bittersweetness and color to Worcestershire. Sugar also helps balance sourness.
-
Vinegar – Vinegar adds bright acidity necessary to cut through rich flavors. Malt vinegar is often used.
-
Spices – The exact spice blend varies, but cloves, chili pepper, nutmeg, and cinnamon are often included.
-
Soy sauce – Many brands add fermented soy sauce for extra umami savoriness.
Why Anchovies Are so Important
Now back to the anchovies. These tiny fish are essential for both the flavor and the umami mouthfeel of Worcestershire sauce. When used in small quantities, anchovies add complexity without a strong “fishy” taste.
Anchovies contain high levels of glutamic and inosinic acids. These compounds produce savory umami flavors when combined with other ingredients. Worcestershire sauce simply wouldn’t have the same meaty, rich taste without those anchovies.
Should Vegetarians Avoid Worcestershire Sauce?
Since traditional Worcestershire sauce contains anchovies, is it off limits for vegetarians and vegans? Not necessarily. Some brands actually produce vegetarian and vegan Worcestershire sauces without fish.
Meatless versions swap the anchovies for ingredients like soy sauce, mushrooms, and hydrolyzed vegetable protein (HVP) to achieve that savory umami flavor. As long as you read the label and avoid brands containing anchovy extract, Worcestershire can be vegetarian-friendly.
Gluten-Free and Low-Sodium Options
These days you can also find Worcestershire sauce versions catering to other dietary needs. Gluten-free varieties are made without wheat for people who are gluten intolerant. Lower sodium options allow those limiting salt to still enjoy Worcestershire’s flavor.
How to Use Worcestershire Sauce
Worcestershire sauce is a flexible flavor enhancer. Its balanced sweet, sour, salty, savory profile works in many recipes:
-
Marinades and sauces – Add Worcestershire to steak marinades, BBQ sauce, cocktail sauce, etc.
-
Soups and stews – Add umami flavor to dishes like French onion soup, beef stew, and pot roast.
-
Grilled meats – Brush on chicken, pork chops, ribs, burgers, etc while grilling.
-
Casseroles and braises – Mix into meatloaf, pot pies, pulled pork, roast chicken, etc.
-
Bloody Marys – Spike tomato juice and make Caesar salad dressing.
-
Cheese fondues – It complements gooey cheese fondues and rarebits.
So while Worcestershire sauce does traditionally contain anchovies, that doesn’t have to stop vegetarians from using it. Check the label carefully and you can take advantage of Worcestershire’s savory magic, whether you eat meat or not. A dash of this complex, fermented sauce can make many dishes irresistible.
2 365 Organic Worcestershire Sauce
Whole Foods’ 365 spin-off range offers several, affordable plant-based products, including Organic Worcestershire Sauce. It’s a little thicker than the original recipe, but still just as tasty.Check it out
If you’re looking for a fish-free Worcestershire sauce, perfect for Passover recipes, try Imitation Worcestershire Sauce from Haddar, which specializes in kosher products.Check it out
12 The Chilli Mash Company
As the name implies, this UK brand has a niche specialty: chili mash. But that’s not all it offers. On its virtual shelves, you can also find a selection of spicy condiments, like Sweet Bonnet Hot Sauce, as well as Carolina Reaper Jam, and more mild options, like VWorcs, its own anchovy-free Worcestershire sauce.Check it out
UK brand Bonson is on a mission to prove that plant-based ingredients can do everything that animal ingredients can do, but taste even better. That’s why it makes everything from Organic Kofu Steak to Organic Worcester Sauce (a match made in heaven, by the way.)Check it out
How Lea & Perrins Makes Worcestershire Sauce Using A 185-Year-Old Recipe | Regional Eats
Can you use Worcestershire sauce instead of fish sauce?
Worcestershire sauce can also be used as an alternative to fish sauce if you want to try a slightly different flavour profile in your marinades. A bloody mary-inspired tomato sauce with a dash of Worcestershire sauce is great for prawns while classic oysters kilpatrick see a dash of it added to liven up the flavours of bacon.
What is the healthier substitute of worcestershire sauce?
The healthier substitutes of Worcestershire sauce are: 1. Soy sauce: Soy sauce doesn’t have quite the same tartness or spice as the original. This substitute works for all recipes and has similar consistency and dissolves well. 2. Tamarind paste+ soy sauce+ white vinegar: This combination of ingredients are close to Worcestershire sauce. 3. Fish sauce: Fish sauce is a bit of a funky condiment that is made from fermented anchovies. 4. A1 steak sauce: It is a little thicker than Worcestershire sauce but will taste very similar. It is made with ingredients like tomato paste, raisin paste, vinegar, corn syrup, garlic, onions and other flavorings.
Does Worcestershire sauce have a lot of flavor?
And that means there’s a lot of flavor. Worcestershire sauce is really an umami delivery vehicle, a cousin to fish sauce or soy sauce that the family kind of forgot about. And we tend to forget about it, too—but at the end of the day, you can use Worcestershire to add flavor to anything saucy much in the same way you’d use soy or fish sauce.
Can you use Worcestershire sauce in English dishes?
The shallots and garlic it contains can complement the sauce’s other savory ingredients. You can also use it to thin the sauce out to keep it from being too viscous. Do use Worcestershire Sauce in English dishes. Worcestershire sauce is an English sauce formulated for English taste preferences.