Both Dungeness crab and Blue Crab are popular crabs in the US, but they taste, live in different places, are bigger, and are used in different ways in cooking.
Dungeness crabs are primarily found on the west coast of North America, ranging from Alaska to California. They inhabit cold waters and are commonly harvested in the Pacific Ocean. Blue crabs, on the other hand, live mostly along the Atlantic coast of North America, from the Gulf of Mexico to the northeastern United States. They are often found in brackish or saltwater estuaries and coastal areas.
The place where the crab comes from impacts the quality of the meat as well as the economy and the environment. First, the water quality and habitat directly influences the health and safety of the seafood. Polluted water crabs can have harmful contaminants in them, while crabs that come from clean water are much less likely to eat pollutants or toxins.
Also, seafood that is caught in a way that doesn’t harm the environment helps keep crab populations healthy for future generations. Supporting local fisheries and crabbers can also help fishing communities’ economies.
Because Alaska and the Pacific Northwest care about the environment, Dungeness Crab is almost always raised and caught in a way that doesn’t harm the environment. Blue Crab, on the other hand, is harvested heavily and their population often faces dramatic declines. This is why, at Premier Catch, we always source sustainability and are proud supporters of Dungeness.
Nope! Dungeness crabs are larger than blue crabs. Dungeness crabs are one of the biggest crabs that can be eaten. They can be up to 10 inches wide. In comparison, blue crabs are smaller, with shells ranging from 4 to 7 inches.
Size of the crab can affect many things, such as the amount of meat it produces, its taste, texture, how it is cooked, and how meaty the bite is. Smaller crabs have less meat and a sweeter flavor. Dungeness crab are larger than blue crab, making the meat richer and more flavorful.
Dungeness crabs have a distinctive appearance with a wide, rounded body and reddish-brown color. They are known for their large, meaty claws and legs. Blue crabs are aptly named due to their blue coloration, especially on their claws and legs. They have a more oval-shaped body with blue and green hues.
Dungeness Crab and Blue Crab each have a unique taste and texture. Dungeness crab meat is known for its sweet, delicate flavor with a slightly nutty undertone. The meat is often described as tender, flaky, and succulent. Whereas, blue crab meat has a sweet flavor but a brinier taste.
Most of the time, Dungeness Crab is the crowd favorite because of its rich flavor, tender meat, and reputation as a gourmet food.
Dungeness crab is often preferred for its large, easily accessible meat. It is often served whole or as crab meat in dishes like crab cakes, crab salads, and crab bisque because of this. Since they are smaller, blue crab is typically used in smaller quantities. Blue crab is popular in various regional dishes, such as Maryland-style crab cakes and gumbo. It is also used in crab boils and as a topping for sushi rolls.
The season for blue crabs runs from spring to late fall, and the season for Dungeness crabs, depending on where you live, runs from December to August.
We make it easy to enjoy Dungeness crab all year, even though the season is shorter, by cleaning, cooking, and freezing our crab right after it’s caught. This makes sure that when it gets to our customers, it is at its best in terms of quality, purity, and taste. We also make our Dungeness crab into “Snap-N-Eats,” which is a special process that involves scoring each part of the leg separately. This makes it very easy to just “snap and eat.” Our Dungeness crab can be served cold after being defrosted, or they can be steamed, boiled, baked, or added to your favorite crab recipe to make it warmer.
In our meat-only packs, you can enjoy the sweet, juicy taste of wild Dungeness crab without all the work and mess. We clean, cook, and then take the meat out of the shell for you, just like with our Dungeness Crab Snap-N-Eats. We vacuum seal the meat and freeze it for the ultimate treat all year round. They come in a 1-pound package and can be used to make crab cakes, salads, pasta, omelets, and dips.
From their habitat, size, appearance, taste, and culinary applications, the difference between Dungeness and Blue crab is stark. Premier Catch is dedicated to providing the best seafood that is sourced in a way that doesn’t harm the environment. That’s why we love Wild Alaska Dungeness Crab!
Sign up for exclusive offers, free recipes & new product releases. 10% off when you join!
Blue crab is one of the most iconic seafood dishes in the United States especially for lovers of Chesapeake Bay cuisine. With its bright blue claws and sweet, delicate flavor blue crab is a favorite among seafood connoisseurs. But for those who have never tried it, the question remains what does blue crab actually taste like?
In this article, we’ll cover everything you need to know about the unique flavor of blue crab meat We’ll explore how it compares to other types of crab, what makes its taste so distinctive, and the best ways to cook blue crab to bring out its natural sweetness Whether you’re new to blue crab or already a die-hard fan, read on to get the full scoop on this delicious crustacean.
An Overview of Blue Crab’s Flavor Profile
Blue crab has a sweet, delicate flavor that is slightly briny from the crab’s ocean habitat The meat has a soft, flaky texture and a signature reddish tint from natural pigments called carotenoids Unlike king crab or snow crab which can taste more robust, blue crab is prized for its mild, slightly nutty taste. It is not as rich as some other crab varieties, but has a pleasant sweetness balanced by the subtle saltiness from residing in brackish waters.
When cooked properly, blue crab meat should be moist, tender and succulent. The claws contain the largest lump pieces of meat, while the body has smaller flakes. Connoisseurs consider blue crab claw meat to be the sweetest and most flavorful. The leg meat tends to be drier with a stronger iodine taste. For the best experience, most people prefer eating meat from the claws and body.
How Blue Crab Compares to Other Popular Crab Varieties
To understand the uniqueness of blue crab’s flavor, it helps to compare it to other popular crab species:
-
Dungeness crab – Found on the Pacific coast, this crab has sweeter and more tender meat compared to blue crab. It lacks the soft brininess of blue crab.
-
King crab – With its firm texture and robust, saline flavor, king crab tastes quite different from the delicate blue crab.
-
Snow crab – Snow crab legs have a pleasantly sweet taste, but the meat is not quite as tender as blue crab.
-
Stone crab – Harvested off the Florida coast, stone crab has very firm, lobster-like meat with a stronger marine flavor.
While flavors vary slightly depending on the harvested region, blue crab offers a one-of-a-kind eating experience featuring supreme sweetness with just a hint of briny undertones. This nuanced flavor profile stands out from other crab varieties.
What Makes Blue Crab’s Taste So Distinctive
So what accounts for blue crab’s distinctive sweet-yet-briny flavor? There are a few key factors:
-
Diet – Blue crabs are opportunistic omnivores, feeding on clams, fish, plants and even smaller crabs. This varied diet contributes to blue crab’s complex flavor.
-
Habitat – Living in estuaries and salt marshes gives blue crab meat a mildly briny taste. Crabs from less salty waters tend to be blander.
-
Seasoning – Unlike some other seafood, blue crab is eaten with minimal seasoning. This allows its natural sweetness to shine through.
-
Cooking method – Quick steaming, sautéing or broiling helps preserve blue crab’s signature succulence and prevents overpowering its delicate notes.
The result is tender, sweet flaky meat with hints of the sea – the hallmarks of a great blue crab.
How to Cook Blue Crab to Bring Out the Best Flavor
To get the optimal sweet-briny taste of blue crab, it’s key to choose the right cooking method:
-
Steaming – This quick cooking technique nicely seals in moisture and flavor. Whole blue crabs or clusters are ideal steamed.
-
Sautéing – Cooking picked crab meat in butter or oil briefly to heat through while retaining moisture. Great for dishes like crab cakes.
-
Broiling – Adding a char from broiling or grilling gives a touch of smoky flavor. Works well with crab cakes or stuffed crab shells.
-
Boiling – Submerging whole crabs in seasoned liquid infuses spices and seafood aromas. Popular for Southern crab boils.
-
Baking – Gentle baking keeps crab meat tender. Excellent for casseroles and crab-stuffed fish.
Avoid overcooking blue crab, which can cause it to dry out and lose its signature sweetness. Follow suggested cook times for different prep methods. Checking for opaque, flaky meat will ensure perfectly cooked crab.
Simple Ideas for Showcasing Blue Crab’s Natural Flavor
From appetizers to entrees, blue crab shines when allowed to be the star. Here are some tasty ways to serve it:
-
Crab cakes – Pan-fried patties of fresh crab meat, bread crumbs and spices. A classic!
-
Chilled crab salad – Flaky crab tossed in a light dressing makes a refreshing salad.
-
Crab dip – Warm, creamy dip is irresistible when loaded with crab meat.
-
Crab stuffed fish – Fillets like flounder or snapper baked with a crab filling.
-
Whole steamed crabs – Hard to beat whole freshly steamed crabs with melted butter.
-
Crab boils or bakes – Groups feast on whole crabs, corn and potatoes simmered in seasoned water.
-
Crab bisque – Pureed crab makes a velvety, decadent soup.
-
Crab omelet – An omelet filled with crab is an elegant breakfast.
-
Crab mac and cheese – The ultimate comfort food gets even better with crab.
Where to Buy Blue Crab
For the best tasting crab, purchase raw blue crab from quality local fish markets, seafood counters or reputable online retailers like Premier Catch Seafood. Be sure the crab appears moist and smells of the fresh ocean. A crab boil is also a fun way to cook your own fresh or live crabs.
Pasteurized crab meat in cans or sealed containers from grocery stores works well for convenient dishes like crab cakes. When thawed, frozen crab can also provide tasty meat for recipes or crab cakes. Avoid any crab meat with an unpleasant fishy or ammonia odor.
Satisfy Your Crab Craving
With its one-of-a-kind sweet and faintly briny flavor, tender meat texture, and beautiful coloring, it’s easy to see why blue crab is such a cherished delicacy. This quick look at blue crab’s taste profile, comparisons to other crabs, flavor influences, best cooking methods and ideal dishes should give you helpful guidance on how to buy, prepare and savor this coastal classic.
The next time you see fresh blue crab on a restaurant menu or at the market, go ahead and give it a try. Chances are good you’ll soon be hooked on the sweet taste and delightful experience of blue crab. And if you’re already a fellow blue crab lover, hopefully this article provided some helpful new insights into appreciating this scrumptious seafood. Happy crab eating, everyone!
Shop Best Selling Seafood Bundles
Both Dungeness crab and Blue Crab are popular crabs in the US, but they taste, live in different places, are bigger, and are used in different ways in cooking.
Where are they harvested?
Dungeness crabs are primarily found on the west coast of North America, ranging from Alaska to California. They inhabit cold waters and are commonly harvested in the Pacific Ocean. Blue crabs, on the other hand, live mostly along the Atlantic coast of North America, from the Gulf of Mexico to the northeastern United States. They are often found in brackish or saltwater estuaries and coastal areas.
Why does the source matter?
The place where the crab comes from impacts the quality of the meat as well as the economy and the environment. First, the water quality and habitat directly influences the health and safety of the seafood. Polluted water crabs can have harmful contaminants in them, while crabs that come from clean water are much less likely to eat pollutants or toxins.
Also, seafood that is caught in a way that doesn’t harm the environment helps keep crab populations healthy for future generations. Supporting local fisheries and crabbers can also help fishing communities’ economies.
Because Alaska and the Pacific Northwest care about the environment, Dungeness Crab is almost always raised and caught in a way that doesn’t harm the environment. Blue Crab, on the other hand, is harvested heavily and their population often faces dramatic declines. This is why, at Premier Catch, we always source sustainability and are proud supporters of Dungeness.
Are they the same size?
Nope! Dungeness crabs are larger than blue crabs. Dungeness crabs are one of the biggest crabs that can be eaten. They can be up to 10 inches wide. In comparison, blue crabs are smaller, with shells ranging from 4 to 7 inches.
Why does size matter?
Size of the crab can affect many things, such as the amount of meat it produces, its taste, texture, how it is cooked, and how meaty the bite is. Smaller crabs have less meat and a sweeter flavor. Dungeness crab are larger than blue crab, making the meat richer and more flavorful.
How can I spot dungy and blue crab?
Dungeness crabs have a distinctive appearance with a wide, rounded body and reddish-brown color. They are known for their large, meaty claws and legs. Blue crabs are aptly named due to their blue coloration, especially on their claws and legs. They have a more oval-shaped body with blue and green hues.
Which crab tastes better?
Dungeness Crab and Blue Crab each have a unique taste and texture. Dungeness crab meat is known for its sweet, delicate flavor with a slightly nutty undertone. The meat is often described as tender, flaky, and succulent. Whereas, blue crab meat has a sweet flavor but a brinier taste.
Most of the time, Dungeness Crab is the crowd favorite because of its rich flavor, tender meat, and reputation as a gourmet food.
What recipes are best for Dungeness and Blue Crab?
Dungeness crab is often preferred for its large, easily accessible meat. It is often served whole or as crab meat in dishes like crab cakes, crab salads, and crab bisque because of this. Since they are smaller, blue crab is typically used in smaller quantities. Blue crab is popular in various regional dishes, such as Maryland-style crab cakes and gumbo. It is also used in crab boils and as a topping for sushi rolls.
When is it available?
The season for blue crabs runs from spring to late fall, and the season for Dungeness crabs, depending on where you live, runs from December to August.
We make it easy to enjoy Dungeness crab all year, even though the season is shorter, by cleaning, cooking, and freezing our crab right after it’s caught. This makes sure that when it gets to our customers, it is at its best in terms of quality, purity, and taste. We also make our Dungeness crab into “Snap-N-Eats,” which is a special process that involves scoring each part of the leg separately. This makes it very easy to just “snap and eat.” Our Dungeness crab can be served cold after being defrosted, or they can be steamed, boiled, baked, or added to your favorite crab recipe to make it warmer.
In our meat-only packs, you can enjoy the sweet, juicy taste of wild Dungeness crab without all the work and mess. We clean, cook, and then take the meat out of the shell for you, just like with our Dungeness Crab Snap-N-Eats. We vacuum seal the meat and freeze it for the ultimate treat all year round. They come in a 1-pound package and can be used to make crab cakes, salads, pasta, omelets, and dips.
Join us in Eating Wild!
From their habitat, size, appearance, taste, and culinary applications, the difference between Dungeness and Blue crab is stark. Premier Catch is dedicated to providing the best seafood that is sourced in a way that doesn’t harm the environment. That’s why we love Wild Alaska Dungeness Crab!
How to PROPERLY Pick & Eat Maryland Blue Crabs
What do blue crabs taste like?
Other sought-after parts of the blue crab include the roe, which makes an excellent garnish and is revered in Chinese cuisine. The flavor-packed spheres come from the female crab and turn bright orange after cooking. Also, the tomalley (aka “mustard”) is found in all blue crabs.
What is a blue crab?
Blue crabs are a type of crustacean that are commonly found in the coastal waters of the Eastern United States and the Gulf of Mexico. They are known for their sweet, delicate meat. Scientific name: Callinectes sapidus Predators and Threats: Larger fish, birds, marine mammals, and human interferance Unique adaptations: Can regenerate lost limbs
What does crab taste like?
And like other types of seafood that look a bit strange compared to the more familiar pieces of ham, chicken, or steak, crab can also have the same strange look (obviously) as well as a strong fishy smell. While crab may have a strong smell, the taste isn’t as fishy as many other water-dwelling animals. So,
Are blue crabs hard to cook?
If you’ve never cooked fresh blue crabs, it might seem a bit intimidating. But, it’s actually not very hard at all—and the sweet crabmeat is well worth a little bit of manual labor. Found all along the East Coast and into the Gulf, this crab’s name comes from the color of its shell.