One of the most popular foods consumed on St. Patricks Day. Corned beef comes in two primary types: gray and red. The method of processing and the quantity of salt used during the curing process are the main distinctions between the two types.
The gray variety is primarily popular in New England and is frequently referred to as Boston Irish corned beef. Outside of New England, gray corned beef can be difficult to locate. In every other country and is typically available all year round, red corned beef is more prevalent. The red variety is frequently referred to as corned beef in the New York style.
The type of salt used during the curing process is the primary distinction between these two varieties of corned beef. Red corned beef is cured using sodium nitrate. This prevents the meat from oxidizing, maintaining its red color. Red corned beef is also spiced, but gray corned beef is only salted during the curing process. Without the use of any other spices, gray corned beef is placed in a salted brine.
Red corned beef is thought to taste better than gray corned beef. The gray meet is softer and sweeter. Red corned beef is saltier than gray corned beef. Making corned beef and cabbage is the most well-liked method of eating corned beef.
Corned beef became an Irish-American tradition in the mid 1800s. Instead of serving ham on holidays as they would have done in Europe, Irish immigrants who settled in the New England states occasionally served this type of meat. To create what we now know as corned beef and cabbage, it was combined with potatoes, carrots, and cabbage. It has become a tradition in the U. S. to eat this meal on or around St. Patricks Day. The gray corned beef is found primarily in New England. Additional preservatives are added to the meat to prolong its shelf life, preserving its red hue. Due to these preservatives, corned beef can be shipped across the nation.
The specialty is usually pink, but it looks different around Boston. The Mystery of New England’s Gray Corned Beef In This Story
Irish-Americans will serve corned beef on their tables this Saint Patrick’s Day, a tradition that dates back centuries. Patrick’s Day. However, corned beef in and around Boston appears a little different. Instead of its familiar pink-red color, it’s gray-brown. And nobody really understands why New Englanders prepare corned beef differently.
The color difference is due to one ingredient: nitrates, either in the form of sodium nitrate or saltpeter, added into the salty brine that gives brisket its corned taste and flavor. Nitrates preserve meat and give it a reddish color, two compelling qualities that make red corned beef much more popular than gray. Nitrates, which are potentially carcinogenic, have long been controversial. But in an age before refrigeration, they were a blessing. In the 17th century, even saltpeter-containing gunpowder was rubbed on meat.
Without added nitrates, corned beef is a dull gray. It’s uncommon to find, except in certain regions. “[Gray] corned beef is eaten within a fifty-mile radius of Boston, including a few towns in New Hampshire,” writes Joan Nathan, author of An American Folklife Cookbook.
Red corned beef has been the standard for hundreds of years due to the benefits of nitrates. The Virginia Housewife, one of the earliest and most influential cookbooks in America, instructs readers to rub brisket with tablespoons of saltpeter. But it’s unclear why Bostonians chose not to season their beef with saltpeter. Robert S. It’s a mystery to him too, according to Cox, a writer of books on New England specialties like chowder, cranberries, and pie. He remarks, “It’s gray, like the late-winter skies in New England, but I don’t get the impression that corned beef is that poetic. ”.
The gray/pink dichotomy is especially visible this time of year, as people prepare corned beef and cabbage. But according to The Oxford Encyclopedia of Food and Drink, not only is the beef not naturally pink, corned beef with cabbage isn’t really an Irish specialty. On the Emerald Isle, a festive St. Paddy’s Day meal would include lamb or bacon. Instead, Irish-American corned beef and cabbage is a mash-up of different food traditions, one of which may hold the answer to the origin of gray corned beef.
In the 19th century, Irish immigrants to the United States had a wealth of experience raising, curing, and exporting beef for the English. In the United States, beef was significantly less expensive, and many communities adopted it as a staple, such as the preserved meats found in Jewish delicatessens. Irish immigrants quickly learned about another custom: New England’s boiled dinner when they settled in New England, particularly in the Boston area. It quickly gained popularity among Irish-Americans and was made up of corned beef and vegetables that were boiled for hours. It’s frequently made with the enigmatic gray corned beef, at least in Boston.
Al Cohen, a 79-year-old butcher and grocery store employee at Bell’s Market in South Boston since the 1960s, is the person most likely to be familiar with the history of Boston’s gray corned beef. Over four generations, his family has operated markets in Boston while producing gray corned beef. Cohen, who uses a family recipe to make corned beef by the barrel, denies knowing when the specialty was first created. Customers who request the red variety at Bell’s are directed to the supermarket because he prefers it and doesn’t sell it there. The 900 pounds of what he proudly refers to as “New England gray corned beef” that he made in the previous week, however, will all be gone before St. Patrick’s Day.
Gastro Obscura covers the world’s most wondrous food and drink. Sign up for our email, delivered twice a week.
Using an ad blocker?
To create and compile stories about the world’s undiscovered wonders, we rely on ad revenue. Consider becoming a member to support our work for as little as $5 per month.
To stay up to date on the world’s undiscovered wonders, follow us on Twitter.
Follow us on Facebook to stay up to date on the world’s undiscovered wonders.
Want a Free Book?Sign up for our newsletter and enter to win the second edition of our book, Atlas Obscura: An Explorer’s Guide to the World’s Hidden Wonders.
Add Some Wonder to Your InboxEvery weekday we compile our most wondrous stories and deliver them straight to you.
AOC-full-screen, AOC-heart-solid, AOC-flipboard, AOC-globe, AOC-pocket, AOC-share, AOC-cancel, AOC-arrow-right, AOC-arrow-left, AOC-ticket, AOC-place-entry, AOC-accommodation, AOC-activity-level, AOC-add-a-photo, AOC-add-box, AOC-add-shape,
NE Grey Corned Beef
FAQ
Does gray corned beef taste different?
Red corned beef is thought to taste better than gray corned beef. The gray meet is softer and sweeter. Red corned beef is saltier than gray corned beef. Making corned beef and cabbage is the most well-liked method of eating corned beef.
Is GREY corned beef good?
A saltwater brine is used to cure gray corned beef for at least two weeks. The absence of preservatives in this brine makes the grey corned beef a fantastic choice for those trying to stay away from nitrates and nitrites. The grey corned beef can also be seasoned to your preferences because the brine isn’t seasoned.
What is the difference between gray corned beef and red corned beef?
Both red and grey corned beef are made from brisket, but the difference lies in the method of curing. While salt is the only ingredient used to cure grey brisket, which is most often associated with New England, red corned beef gets its color from sodium nitrate.
What’s the difference between pink and GREY corned beef?
Instead of its familiar pink-red color, it’s gray-brown. And nobody really understands why New Englanders prepare corned beef differently. Nitrates, either in the form of sodium nitrate or saltpeter, added to the salty brine that gives brisket its corned taste and flavor, are the cause of the color difference.