One of the best things about a traditional New England lobster dinner is how simple it is to make. No complicated sauces, no fancy techniques, no need to fire up the oven on a hot day. And you need only one pot. But just because it’s simple doesn’t mean that you can’t run into trouble. In fact, because this is such an elemental meal, it’s important to get the details right. Mostly, that means cooking your lobster the right way. Here are five of the most common mistakes in cooking lobster, and how to avoid them.
Lobster is one of the most beloved shellfish delicacies. When properly prepared, the meat should be tender and succulent with a sweet, briny flavor. However, nothing can ruin a lobster dinner faster than biting into a chewy, rubbery piece of meat. If you’ve experienced tough, unappetizing lobster before, you likely wondered – why is my lobster so rubbery and how can I fix it?
Don’t worry, with a few easy cooking adjustments and preparations, you can ensure your lobster turns out tender and delicious every time. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover the top reasons for rubbery lobster and provide tips to help you avoid this common cooking mistake. You’ll learn how to select, store, prep, and cook lobster properly for flawless texture and taste.
Common Causes of Rubbery Lobster Meat
Before we dive into solutions, let’s first review the main culprits that can lead to unappealing chewy or rubbery lobster meat
-
Overcooking – Cooking the lobster too long causes proteins to become tough and rigid. This is one of the biggest reasons for rubbery meat
-
Incorrect cooking method – Boiling can make the meat soggy or mushy if done improperly
-
Old lobster – Meat texture deteriorates as lobster ages after being caught. Always cook live lobster as soon as possible.
-
Improper storage – Storing in plastic bags or fresh water removes flavor and causes proteins to break down.
-
Low-quality lobster – Weak, nutrient-deprived lobsters prone to having rubbery texture. Select healthy, active lobsters.
-
Incorrect preparation – Not splitting, tenderizing, or brining appropriately before cooking.
Now that you know potential causes, let’s go over step-by-step ways to help avoid rubbery lobster meat when cooking at home.
Tips to Prevent Rubbery Lobster Every Time
Follow these top tips when handling, prepping, and cooking lobster:
Select Fresh, Active Live Lobsters
-
Look for lively lobsters that move claws and tails when handled. Avoid lethargic or sickly looking ones.
-
Choose heaviest lobsters for size since meat yield correlates to weight.
-
Only purchase from reputable sellers and check lobster quality frequently.
Store Correctly
-
Keep lobsters cool at 35-40°F, but do not freeze if cooking live.
-
Do not store lobster in fresh water or sealed plastic bags. Use damp paper towels in breathable container.
-
Cook live lobsters within 24 hours for optimal freshness and texture. Do not store over 48 hours.
Prep Properly Before Cooking
-
Split lobster tails along the back of the shell before cooking for even cooking.
-
Consider tenderizing the meat by brining tails briefly in salt water.
-
Crack claws, cut body, and remove rubber bands before cooking if desired. Leave intact if opting for presentation.
Avoid Overcooking
-
Test doneness early and often. Lobster overcooks quickly.
-
For boiling, cook just 2-3 minutes after the water returns to a boil.
-
For broiling, watch closely and baste meat frequently with butter to prevent drying out.
-
Cook claws, tails, and bodies separately since they require different times.
Use Correct Cooking Methods
-
Steaming is gentler and results in tender meat. Avoid boiling which can make meat soggy.
-
Broil, grill, or roast tails and claws instead of boiling for firmer texture.
-
Bake, stuff, or sauté lobster meat as alternatives to boiling whole lobsters.
Step-by-Step Instructions for Perfectly Cooked Lobster
Follow these simple step-by-step instructions for cooking tender, juicy lobster every time:
Ingredients
- Live lobster(s) or raw lobster tails
- Butter, olive oil, seasoning
- Lemon wedges
Directions
-
Select lively live lobsters and store properly until ready to cook.
-
Prep lobsters before cooking: Split tails, remove rubber bands, crack claws, and cut body if desired.
-
Bring water to a full rolling boil if steaming or boiling. Heat broiler, grill or pan if cooking tails or claws.
-
Add whole lobsters or tails to boiling water or steamer and cook for only 2-3 minutes after returning to a boil.
-
Broil, grill or sauté tails and claws for 3-4 minutes per side until opaque. Baste with butter.
-
Check for doneness frequently. Meat should be opaque white, not translucent. Remove immediately to avoid overcooking.
-
Serve with melted butter, lemon wedges, fresh herbs, etc. Enjoy immediately for tender texture.
The beauty of lobster is that it doesn’t need much to be delicious! Avoid overcomplicating the preparation and cooking. Follow these guidelines for selecting, storing, prepping and cooking properly, and you’ll be rewarded with tender, succulent lobster meat every time.
Common Lobster Cooking FAQs
Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about achieving tender, perfectly cooked lobster:
How can you tell when lobster is overcooked?
Overcooked lobster will be tough, chewy, and rubbery. The meat will be opaque and dry rather than creamy white and moist when properly cooked.
What is the best way to cook lobster tails?
For tender lobster tails, steam, broil, or grill them. Split shells prior to cooking. Baste with butter while broiling or grilling.
Why does boiled lobster get rubbery?
Boiling can make lobster meat soggy and mushy if cooked too long. It also lacks the caramelization of grilling or broiling.
Should you boil or steam whole lobster?
Steaming is gentler and helps retain moisture better. But boiling infuses flavor if done properly. Both work if you don’t overcook.
How long should I boil pre-cooked lobster tails?
Boil pre-cooked frozen tails just 2-3 minutes to heat through and prevent rubbery texture from overcooking.
Master Lobster Perfection Moving Forward
Serving rubbery lobster is disappointing, but easily avoidable with proper handling and cooking. Now that you know the keys to selecting, storing, preparing and cooking lobster correctly, you can feel confident your next lobster feast will impress everyone with tender, juicy meat.
When in doubt, remember less is more. Resist overcooking, stick to simple seasoned steamed or broiled lobster, and test for doneness frequently. Follow the recommendations in this guide and lobster cooked just right will become your new specialty. Soon your guests will be begging for your tender, mouthwatering lobster recipes.
5 Mistakes to Avoid When Cooking Lobster
- It will take 8 to 12 minutes to boil lobsters that are about 1 to 1½ pounds in weight.
- It takes 9 to 12 minutes to steam lobsters of average size, but it depends on how big they are.
- If you can find soft-shell lobsters in the summer, cook them for two to three minutes less than if you could find hard-shell lobsters in the winter.