We’ve all found ourselves in a situation where we have too much leftover food. You might have made too much for a big dinner, or you might have been a guest and got some leftovers from the host. No matter the reason, you may be wondering if that lobster that you have left over is still safe to eat.
Lobster is a delicious and luxurious seafood that many people love to indulge in. When cooking fresh lobster at home, you may notice that the meat in the tail sometimes has a greenish tint to it. This unexpected coloring can be off-putting, and makes you wonder – is it safe to eat? Why is my lobster tail green?
As it turns out, there are a few natural reasons why lobster meat can take on a green hue. While it may look unappetizing a greenish lobster tail is usually still perfectly fine to eat. Here is a breakdown of the common causes of green lobster meat and when you should be concerned.
Tomalley – The Lobster’s Green Digestive Gland
The most common reason for green-tinged lobster meat is contamination from the lobster’s digestive gland known as the tomalley or hepatopancreas. The tomalley is a soft, green gland found in the body cavity of lobsters and other crustaceans. It functions as both the liver and pancreas.
When cooking whole lobsters or lobster tails with the shell on, it’s easy for some of the green tomalley to leak out during the cooking process and start coloring the meat. This tends to happen more with lobster tails than whole lobsters, since the tomalley is located right next to the meat in the tail.
Tomalley has a very concentrated, almost creamy lobster flavor. Some people consider it a delicacy and will intentionally mix it into sauces or dip lobster meat into the extracted tomalley. However, the green color it imparts is not very visually appealing.
The tomalley coloring itself is harmless, but on rare occasions it can contain higher levels of toxins. The FDA has warned against eating tomalley from lobsters caught in New England areas affected by red tide algae blooms. Normally though, the amount eaten with the meat is a minimal risk.
Overcooking the Lobster
Another culprit behind green lobster syndrome is overcooking. When lobster meat is cooked for too long or at too high of a temperature, it can start changing to an unappetizing grayish-green hue. This is simply an effect of prolonged heat denaturing the protein in the meat.
Overcooking any meat will lead to a drab, greenish-brown tint as the proteins and pigments start to break down. With delicate seafood like lobster, it doesn’t take very long to go from perfectly cooked to overcooked and discolored.
To avoid overcooking lobster, it’s best to steam, boil, or broil the lobster just until the shell turns bright red – about 10-12 minutes for tails. The meat should still have some translucency when properly cooked. Use a thermometer and stop cooking tails once they reach 145°F internally.
Other Causes of Green Lobster Meat
While tomalley and overcooking are the main reasons you might end up with green lobster on your plate, here are a couple other possibilities:
-
Metal cooking tools – Cooking lobster in pots, pans, or steamers made of copper, aluminum, or iron can react with the meat and cause discoloration. Stainless steel is ideal for cooking shellfish.
-
Poor handling – Bruising the raw meat by roughly cracking the shell or improper storage and transport can encourage enzymatic changes and spoilage that alters the color. Handle raw lobster gently and keep chilled.
-
Freezer burn – Frozen lobster that gets dehydrated in the freezer may turn grayish-green around the edges when thawing. Eat thawed lobster soon after rather than refreezing.
-
Undercooking – Rarely, undercooked lobster might appear greenish because the proteins have not been fully denatured by heat. Cook lobster thoroughly to a safe minimum internal temperature.
Is Green Lobster Meat Safe to Eat?
In most cases, you can safely eat lobster meat that has turned green. As we covered, it is usually just a result of contamination from the tomalley during cooking or overcooking the meat. Neither issue presents any real health concerns.
Use your best judgment checking for other signs of spoilage just to be safe. Discard any lobster meat that also smells foul or feels excessively slimy. Make sure whole lobster and tails were still alive right before cooking.
If the green color is very minimal and the rest of the meat looks normal, you can simply cut away the greenish portions. Greenish meat near the head end of the tail is more likely tomalley contamination, while greenish meat near the middle is more likely overcooking.
Ideally, try to prevent green lobster in the first place. Cook tails separately from whole lobsters, and consider splitting lobster tails before cooking to access and remove the digestive gland. This will minimize the risk of tomalley spreading into the meat.
Additionally, be very careful not to overcook lobster. Check it frequently and remove meat from heat as soon as it is opaque and cooked through. Better to slightly undercook than overcook.
How to Prevent Green Lobster Meat
Here are some top tips to keep your lobster meat looking appetizingly white instead of unappetizingly green:
- Separate tails from whole lobsters and remove digestive tracts before cooking
- Cook tails split top-side up to avoid leakage onto meat
- Steam, boil, or broil just until opaque – do not overcook
- Use a thermometer and stop cooking at 145°F
- Allow shells to turn red, but remove before shells blacken or burn
- Avoid using copper, iron, or aluminum pots and utensils
- Chill raw lobster right up until ready to cook
- After cooking, remove meat from shells immediately
- Store cooked lobster chilled in an airtight container
- Do not re-freeze previously frozen lobster meat
With proper handling and cooking, you can feel confident serving bright white, deliciously tender lobster tail at your next dinner party. Don’t let fears over what causes green lobster meat stop you from enjoying this gourmet treat. Just take steps to prevent overexposure to tomalley, overcooking, and improper storage.
What If My Lobster Tail Is Green?
If despite your best efforts, you still end up with a green-tinged lobster tail, take a close look at it before deciding whether to serve it or not. Here are a few determining factors:
-
Where is it green? Green concentrated around the head end suggests tomalley contamination, while green in the middle or by the fin end is more likely overcooked.
-
How green is it? A very dull or faint greenish tint is less concerning than very vivid bright green coloring.
-
What is the texture like? Rubbery, chewy meat can mean overcooking. Soft, mushy meat may mean spoilage.
-
Does it smell bad? Give it a big whiff. Rancid, sulfurous, or ammonia odors mean it’s not safe to eat.
-
When in doubt, throw it out! If the lobster smells funky at all, just don’t risk getting sick.
Once you determine it’s not spoiled, you can try salvaging mildly green meat by cutting away any intensely colored portions. Use the remaining good meat right away and be sure to adjust your cooking method going forward.
Cooking Perfectly Colored Lobster Meat Every Time
Cooking lobster tail or lobster in general takes some practice to master. But you’ll get the hang of how to avoid green lobster meat with experience. Here are some fail-safe cooking tips:
-
Start with quality seafood – Buy fresh, raw, whole lobster tails from a trusted fish market or grocer. Make sure they are still alive when purchased.
-
Separate the meat – Cut raw tails lengthwise and remove the digestive tract. Rinse the meat well.
-
Skewer the tail – Thread a skewer through the meat to keep it straight while broiling or grilling.
-
Cook quickly over high heat – Broil, grill, steam, or boil just until opaque, about 3-4 minutes per side.
-
Watch closely – Stay close by and frequently check doneness to prevent overcooking.
-
Remove immediately – As soon as the minimum safe internal temperature is reached, remove from heat.
-
Check the middle – The thickest part of the tail should be pearly white or very faint pink when properly cooked.
-
Chill properly – Place cooked meat into an airtight container and refrigerate within 2 hours. Use within 3-4 days.
Follow these tips and you’ll be rewarded with beautiful, restaurant-quality lobster tails at home. Don’t let the occasional green lobster scare you away from making this impressive seafood.
Frequently Asked Questions About Green Lobster Meat
Here are answers to some common questions about causes of green lobster meat and what to do about it:
How Long Does Lobster Meat Last?
The answer to this question depends on whether or not your lobster meat is cooked. Uncooked lobster meat lasts only a few hours—this is why most lobsters are boiled alive at restaurants.
Lobster meat that has been cooked can be kept in the fridge for three to four days or frozen for several months.
Signs Your Lobster Has Gone Bad
Have you thought about whether that lobster is still safe to eat after four days (or four months for frozen lobster)? Thankfully, bad lobster meat is pretty easy to pick out. If you want to know if you should heat it up again in the oven, look for these signs:
Open the bag or box of lobster and give it a good sniff. Do you immediately turn away? Lobster should never smell bad, so if you scrunch your nose up after a quick sniff, you should probably not eat it.