Finding it impossible to distinguish between fava beans vs. lima beans and decide which one is right for your recipe?.
We get it. It’s not always easy to tell the difference between lima beans and fava beans because they are both legumes and usually green.
But don’t worry—we’re going to explain the differences between these two healthy beans, including their different tastes, textures, and cooking needs.
Are Lima Beans Fava Beans? Unveiling Their Key Similarities and Differences
Many people get confused between lima beans and fava beans, wondering if they are in fact the same legume. It’s easy to see why there’s uncertainty. After all, these two beans share a similar starchy, hearty quality and green color.
However, lima beans and fava beans are not the same While they belong to the same botanical family and offer nutritional benefits, there are noticeable differences between them that you should know.
In this article, we’ll compare lima beans vs. fava beans, analyzing how they vary in terms of:
- Flavor and texture
- Culinary uses
- Nutrition
- Availability
- Preparation
Understanding their unique characteristics will equip you to determine when to use one or the other in recipes.
Flavor and Texture
Let’s begin with the most obvious variation how lima beans and fava beans taste and feel on the palate
Lima beans have a mild, sweet, starchy flavor. Their taste is often described as nutty and earthy as well. When cooked, lima beans become soft and creamy. The texture transforms into something rich and satisfying.
Meanwhile, fava beans are bolder in flavor. They taste grassy, yet retain a unique creaminess. Fava beans also have a robust, nutty taste with notes of butter. Even when cooked until tender, fava beans maintain a heartier consistency than buttery lima beans.
Additionally, fava beans can have a slightly bitter undertone. This comes from tannins present in the bean’s skin, which is why fava beans are often peeled.
Culinary Uses
Now let’s explore how lima beans and fava beans differ when it comes to cooking.
Thanks to their neutral flavor, lima beans work well in dishes where you want other ingredients to take center stage. For instance, lima beans are great in hearty soups and stews where they soak up surrounding flavors. They also add a wonderful creaminess to dips and purees.
Meanwhile, fava beans shine when their distinct flavor is highlighted. They lend a unique taste to salads, risottos, and vegetable dishes. Fava beans can even be enjoyed raw, straight out of the shell. Their heartier bite stands up to roasting and grilling too.
In short, fava beans add intrigue to recipes, while lima beans provide a blank canvas to build flavor upon.
Nutrition
Both fava beans and lima beans deliver key nutrients and health benefits. However, there are some nutritional differences between the two legumes.
Lima beans contain more vitamins and minerals overall, offering higher amounts of iron, magnesium, potassium, folate, and thiamine.
Fava beans have fewer calories and carbohydrates per serving compared to lima beans. They also contain special bioactive compounds that may promote blood health.
So lima beans have a slight edge when it comes to general nutrition, while fava beans offer some unique potential benefits.
Availability
The availability of fresh lima beans versus fava beans also differs based on the season.
Fresh fava beans show up in spring and summer. You can spot their large, inedible pods housing the beans inside markets during these warmer months.
Meanwhile, fresh lima beans become available later, in late summer through fall. Their flatter pods containing the beans inside appear during this period.
Outside of their respective seasons, lima beans and fava beans can be purchased dried, canned, or frozen year round. So you can enjoy their virtues no matter the time of year.
Preparation
Preparing fresh lima beans and fava beans requires some work, like shelling, blanching, and peeling. But the process isn’t identical for each.
To prepare fresh fava beans:
- Remove beans from pods
- Blanch for 30 seconds to 1 minute
- Shock in ice bath
- Peel off outer skin
For fresh lima beans:
- Twist pod open to release beans
- Blanch for 2 to 4 minutes depending on size
- Shock in ice bath
- Peel off outer skin
The main difference is that lima beans need a longer blanching time to loosen their skins before peeling. Also, consuming raw lima beans can be toxic, while raw fava beans are safe.
Canned and frozen varieties eliminate the need for prep work beyond a simple rinse before using. Dried beans must be soaked before cooking as well.
The Takeaway
While lima beans and fava beans hail from the same legume family, they have distinct identities. Fava beans offer a bolder flavor and heartier bite, while lima beans provide a starchy creaminess and mild taste. Their culinary roles, nutritional profiles, and availability vary too.
The next time your recipe calls for “beans,” consider which type of bean – fava or lima – would work best based on their unique offerings. Doing so will ensure you end up with the perfect texture and flavor.
Fava Beans vs. Lima Beans: Taste, Texture, and Appearance
Knowing the differences between fava and lima beans in terms of how they look, taste, and feel is important if you need to choose between them for a recipe.
Now that you know about these small but important differences, you can pick the right bean for your recipes based on the taste, mouthfeel, and presentation you want.
Fava beans are typically described as having a rich, buttery, and nutty flavor, especially when eaten fresh. But your palate may detect some slight bitterness from this legume.
Additionally, fava beans have a cheesy undertone and earthy notes that add depth to different recipes.
Lima beans, which are also called butter beans, have a milder flavor than fava beans, though they still have a nutty and earthy taste. This is why they’re ideal for recipes that call for a subtler bean flavor.
They are also sweeter and starchier than fava beans.
If youre expecting a firmer bite, fava beans are your go-to. They maintain a more robust texture after cooking, which offers a satisfying chew.
On the other hand, lima beans are ideal for those who are looking for something softer. They become quite tender when cooked, heading toward a creamy consistency.
Fava beans and lima beans are both found in green pods.
Fava beans can be green, yellow, white, or brown, while lima beans can be light green, off-white, tan, brown, purple, or black.
The two also differ in shape. Lima beans are flat, wide, and moon- or kidney-shaped, and they often lose their shape when they’re cooked.
Meanwhile, fava beans are flat, oval, and often bumpy. Plus, they’re more capable of holding their shape after cooking.
Fava Beans vs. Lima Beans: Safety for Consumption
Even though fava beans and lima beans are usually safe to eat, there are a few things you should know to stay safe.
Fava beans contain vicine and convicine, which can trigger hemolytic anemia in individuals with G6PD deficiency, a condition known as favism.
Because of this risk, fava beans is not safe to consume for those with this disorder.
Important warning: never eat lima beans raw, even in small doses.
These beans contain linamarin, a compound also found in flax and cassava, which releases cyanide in the body once ingested.
Meanwhile, fresh fava beans can be safely consumed raw.
Fava Beans 101
FAQ
Are lima beans the same as fava?
What is another name for fava beans?
What beans are in the lima bean family?