Does Red Lobster Serve Real Lobster? Getting the Facts on Their Seafood

Bill Darden started the famous seafood chain in 1968 because he wanted everyone, not just people who lived near the coast, to be able to get seafood. First, a piece of good news: Red Lobster does not boil lobsters alive—not anymore, at least. A statement on their FAQ section reads, “Unlike some seafood restaurants, Red Lobster does not boil lobsters alive. Our culinary professionals are trained to humanely end the lobsters life moments before they are cooked. There is some disagreement about whether lobsters feel pain, but you can eat the sea creature that is at the heart of this 50-year-old seafood chain without feeling bad about it.

But you might want to think twice before you crack open those shells, drizzle that butter on top, and eat shrimp and other seafood with those famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits. Here are seven secrets Red Lobster would just as soon keep submerged.

Red Lobster is one of the largest and most popular seafood restaurant chains in America. Their menu features a variety of lobster dishes, from whole live Maine lobsters to tender lobster tail. But does the casual dining chain actually serve real, high-quality lobster in their recipes? Let’s explore the truth about lobster at Red Lobster.

An Overview of Lobster on the Red Lobster Menu

Here are some of the key lobster dishes currently featured on the Red Lobster menu

  • Live Maine Lobster – Offered in 1.25 lb and 1.5 lb sizes roasted or steamed. Served with two sides.

  • Twin Maine Lobster Tails – Two cold-water lobster tails roasted with butter. Sizes range from 4-6 oz petites to 8-10 oz tails.

  • Lobster Lover’s Dream – A roasted lobster tail paired with a roasted rock lobster tail. Served with two sides.

  • Today’s Catch – Lobster, Shrimp & Salmon – Grilled salmon topped with lobster meat and shrimp in a lemon basil butter.

In addition to whole lobsters and lobster tails, lobster meat is also used in dishes like Lobster Topped Cod and Seafood Stuffed Flounder.

So clearly, lobster does feature prominently on the Red Lobster menu in various forms. But is it real, high-quality lobster?

Red Lobster Uses Real Lobster Meat

The good news is that yes, Red Lobster does serve real lobster in their recipes, not substitutes. Here’s why you can be confident you’re getting true lobster at Red Lobster:

  • Maine lobster – Their live lobsters and lobster tails are wild-caught in the waters of Maine, known for high-quality lobsters.

  • Lobster meat – Lobster meat used in other dishes like Lobster Topped Cod is real lobster meat, not imitation.

  • Supply chain – Red Lobster has an established supply chain to source real lobster meat. Using substitutes would be more expensive and complex.

  • Consumer awareness – Consumers are knowledgeable about seafood. Passing off imitation lobster would be brand damaging if exposed.

  • Legal compliance – FDA guidelines prohibit labeling imitation seafood as real lobster. This keeps brands honest.

So while you may not think of Red Lobster as a “fine dining” lobster restaurant, they do serve authentic, real Maine lobster in their food.

Potential Concerns About Lobster Quality at Red Lobster

While Red Lobster does use real lobster, some people still have concerns about the quality and freshness of their lobster:

  • Previously frozen – Much of the lobster is previously frozen before being shipped to restaurants. This can diminish texture and flavor vs fresh.

  • Not live – The lobster is pre-cooked so it won’t be as tender as if cooked from live. Many fine dining places cook lobster to order.

  • Not local – Since Red Lobster has nationwide locations, lobster is shipped long distances before reaching some restaurants.

  • High volume – Red Lobster serves a high volume, so supply consistency takes priority over peak freshness.

However, Red Lobster does take steps to maximize lobster quality, like using flash freezing methods to preserve texture after harvesting. And supply chain innovations now allow reasonably fresh seafood to be shipped nationwide.

Taste Reviews: Lobster at Red Lobster Gets Decent Marks

When it comes down to diner’s actual experience of eating lobster at Red Lobster, reviews are generally positive:

  • “The lobster tasted fresh. You could tell it was real lobster, not fake.”

  • “The tails were a good size and had lots of meat. They were tasty dipped in the warm butter.”

  • “While not as sweet as live lobster I’ve had on the wharf, Red Lobster’s lobster dishes still had a nice mild flavor and tender texture.”

  • “You can definitely tell the difference between Red Lobster’s lobster and high-end restaurant lobster. But for the price you pay, it’s decent quality.”

  • “Their lobster dishes may not blow you away, but I’ve never been disappointed with the taste of lobster at Red Lobster.”

So while some lobster aficionados may find it lacks the absolute freshness and depth of flavor that the very best lobster has, most agree the lobster at Red Lobster is palatable and delivers a satisfying taste of lobster.

How Red Lobster Keeps Lobster Prices Low

Part of Red Lobster’s appeal is they make lobster affordable to the average person. But how can they offer dishes like Lobster Lover’s Dream for under $30 when fine dining restaurants charge double that for a basic grilled lobster tail?

Red Lobster is able to keep lobster prices in check through:

  • Buying lobster meat in bulk at low wholesale prices

  • Using previously frozen vs fresh live lobster

  • Having national purchasing power for negotiating deals

  • Lower overhead costs than high-end restaurants

  • Offering smaller lobster sizes like 4-6 oz tails

  • Preparing dishes using partial lobster meat vs whole lobster

So while discerning gourmets may prefer the splurge of a fine dining lobster dinner, Red Lobster succeeds in making lobster more accessible for mass-market tastes.

Is Red Lobster’s Lobster Worth It?

At the end of the day, is enjoying lobster at Red Lobster worth it? Here are some pros and cons to weigh:

Pros

  • Affordable compared to fine dining prices

  • Convenient, casual family dining atmosphere

  • Kids eat free on select nights to make it even more budget-friendly

  • Dipping lobster in warm melted butter is hard to resist!

Cons

  • Lacks freshness and sweetness of live lobster prepared by top chefs

  • Small tail sizes leave some lobster lovers still hungry

  • Not the best choice for special occasions or impressing lobster connoisseurs

Overall, while discerning foodies may pass, for families, couples or lobster newbies on a budget, Red Lobster offers a chance to enjoy real lobster at prices cheaper than higher-end restaurants. The lobster may not be 5-star cuisine but it lets average consumers get an affordable taste of this iconic seafood.

So next time you’re craving lobster, give Red Lobster a try for casual, reasonably-priced lobster fare! Just go in with appropriate expectations for the price point, and you’re likely to have a tasty, if not mind-blowing, lobster experience.

does red lobster serve real lobster

The chain has been caught selling imitation lobster

does red lobster serve real lobster

According to Inside Edition, a few years back Red Lobster was caught offering dishes that claimed to contain lobster but actually used other seafood as a substitute. Some of the dishes, the lobster bisque, in particular, had both lobster and other, cheaper seafood, called langostino, while a few lacked lobster completely. And while langostino is technically a type of lobster, it needs to be labeled as langostino lobster when used as the sole fish, according to the FDA.

The Cheddar Bay Biscuits are fat bombs

does red lobster serve real lobster

Sure, Red Lobsters Cheddar Bay Biscuits may be delicious but that tastiness comes c/o a lot of fat, were sorry to report. According to Fast Food Nutrition, a single 160-calorie Cheddar Bay Biscuit derives 90 of said calories from fat, delivering 10 grams of fat (and 4.5 grams of fat per saturate fat) per little bready blob. But if you want you can buy the mix at stores and you can easily find a copycat recipe for the beloved biscuits.

Which Restaurants May Be Serving You Cheap Fish Instead Of Lobster

Does Red Lobster eat fresh seafood?

The answer: sometimes, and it depends. Red Lobster’s FAQ page says that when the restaurant is able to, it sources fresh seafood. But in other cases, to ensure quality, it is frozen right on the fishing boats or as soon as it reaches the dock before being shipped to restaurants.

Does Red Lobster have lobster?

According to Inside Edition, a few years back Red Lobster was caught offering dishes that claimed to contain lobster but actually used other seafood as a substitute. Some of the dishes, the lobster bisque, in particular, had both lobster and other, cheaper seafood, called langostino, while a few lacked lobster completely.

Where does Red Lobster seafood come from?

As of late 2021, the last time Red Lobster’s “Seafood With Standards” page was updated, the answer seems to be a bit clearer. The restaurant’s seafood is indeed gathered from “all over the world.” For example, its shrimp come from areas in South America and Asia including waters off Ecuador, India, and China.

Does Red Lobster boil lobsters alive?

First, a piece of good news: Red Lobster does not boil lobsters alive—not anymore, at least. A statement on their FAQ section reads, “Unlike some seafood restaurants, Red Lobster does not boil lobsters alive. Our culinary professionals are trained to humanely end the lobster’s life moments before they are cooked.”

Leave a Comment