Where to Buy Beef Wellington from Reputable Sellers

Beef Wellington is the ultimate fancy dinner party showstopper. The tender filet mignon bundled in flaky puff pastry is impressive yet easy to make. But finding high-quality pre-made Beef Wellington can be tricky. You want a seller that uses premium ingredients and proven cooking methods.

So who sells legitimate Beef Wellington that lives up to the hype? Let’s explore some of the best places to buy perfect Beef Wellington online or in stores.

Online Mail Order Companies

Getting Beef Wellington delivered to your door is the most convenient option. Online companies like these ship partially cooked or fully cooked Wellington nationwide.

Kansas City Steaks

• All natural Midwestern beef filet
• Mushroom duxelles filling under puff pastry
• Ships frozen to maintain freshness
• Available in pack of 2, 4 or 6
• Starts at $59.99 per Wellington

Omaha Steaks

• Hand-trimmed beef tenderloin filet
• Proprietary seasoning and stuffing
• Flash frozen and delivered chilled
• Pack of 2 or 4 Wellingtons
• Starts at $89.99 per order

Harry & David

• Beef filet wrapped in flaky dough
• Made with premium Pacific Northwest beef
• Shipped frozen to retain quality
• Sold individually or as a pair
• Starting price of $99.99 each

Williams-Sonoma

• Made with USDA prime beef tenderloin
• Mushroom duxelles and sherry glaze filling
• Ships overnight chilled
• Single serving size Wellington
• Price of $80 for one

Dean & DeLuca

• Certified Angus tenderloin filet
• Made with imported French puff pastry
• Overnight chilled delivery
• Pack of two or four Wellingtons
• Starting at $149 for two

Local Butcher Shops or Meat Markets

Your local butcher may be able to get fresh Beef Wellington or make it custom per your order. Some butchers to check with:

• Pat LaFrieda – NYC area butcher popular with top restaurants
• DeBragga – Specialty meat purveyor in NYC since 1920s
• Lobel’s – Premier butcher with locations across US
• Allen Brothers – Old school Chicago butcher since 1893
• Jamison Farm – Sustainably-raised meats in Pennsylvania

Call around to butchers in your area to see if they carry pre-made Wellington or can custom create it. Expect to pay a premium for the freshly prepared product.

Gourmet Grocery Stores

Many upscale grocers prepare Beef Wellington in their kitchens and sell them in the prepared foods section. Some grocers to check include:

• Whole Foods Market – Their meat department may carry fresh Wellington seasonally.

• Wegmans – Large Northeastern chain with expansive prepared foods.

• Gelson’s – Southern California gourmet market chain.

• Roche Bros. – New England grocery chain known for quality meats.

• PCC Markets – Cooperative grocer in Pacific Northwest with chef-made foods.

• H-E-B – Major Texas grocery chain with artisan foods.

Stop by the prepared foods area or meat counter to check for Wellington availability and pricing. Quantities tend to be limited.

Warehouse Clubs

Occasionally warehouse stores like Costco will offer Beef Wellington as a seasonal specialty item. However, it tends to sell out fast and can be hit or miss. Still worth keeping an eye out for.

Restaurants

Higher end steakhouses sometimes list Beef Wellington on their menus as a dinner entrée. Pricing will be higher than retail, but it’s the full restaurant preparation. Some places to check:

• Mastro’s Steakhouse
• Ruth’s Chris Steak House
• Capital Grille
• Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse
• Emeril’s restaurants

Classic French restaurants may serve Beef Wellington as well. Call ahead to confirm availability on their current menu.

Things to Look for in a Provider

To get the best quality Beef Wellington, look for:

• Reputable seller – Established merchant with safe handling practices

• Premium beef cuts – Filet mignon, beef tenderloin or Chateaubriand

• Freshness – Raw or partially cooked; not fully frozen

• Trusted ingredients – Real butter puff pastry; classic duxelles

• Proven cooking method – Partially or fully baked to perfection

• Individual portions – Single serving Wellingtons, not whole roasts

• Reasonable pricing – Expect to pay $50+ per person

Getting perfect Beef Wellington is worth splurging on. Follow these tips to find a source that meets your standards. With the right Wellington and a glass of red wine, you’ll impress even the pickiest dinner guests.