Can You Wet and Dry Brine a Turkey? A Comprehensive Guide to Brining Your Thanksgiving Bird

All products are independently selected by our editors. If you buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Many people have different ideas about the best way to prepare a turkey for Thanksgiving. To cut right to the chase, the official Epi position is that dry-brining is the only brine method you should think about when preparing a holiday bird. Should you make a dry-brine turkey? Wet-brine? Skip brining entirely? It simply involves sprinkling salt (and possibly a few other seasonings) over the raw turkey and letting it sit in the refrigerator for a few days. It’s far simpler to execute than a wet brine, and the meat is so flavorful that your guests won’t ever complain about dry, tasteless meat again. But let’s back up:

Ah Thanksgiving. A time for family, friends and, of course, a delicious turkey. But how do you ensure your turkey is moist, flavorful, and cooked to perfection? Enter the world of brining. But not just any brining, we’re talking about the ultimate showdown: wet brining vs. dry brining.

What is Brining?

Before we dive into the wet vs. dry debate, let’s understand what brining is all about In layman’s terms, brining is like giving your turkey a saltwater spa treatment This process involves soaking the bird in a solution of salt, water, and sometimes other flavorings, allowing the meat to absorb moisture and become incredibly tender.

The magic of brining lies in the science of osmosis. Salt draws moisture from the turkey into the surrounding brine, creating a concentrated solution. This solution then pushes the seasoned water back into the turkey, resulting in a juicy, flavorful masterpiece.

Wet Brining vs. Dry Brining: The Showdown Begins

So, you’ve decided to brine your turkey but the question remains: wet or dry? Both methods have their own set of pros and cons, making the decision a bit of a head-scratcher. Let’s break down the key differences to help you choose the best method for your Thanksgiving feast.

Wet Brining:

  • Pros:
    • Enhances moisture content, resulting in an incredibly juicy bird.
    • Imparts a deeper flavor profile due to the direct contact with the seasoned water.
    • Easier to manage for beginners as it requires minimal handling of the turkey.
  • Cons:
    • Requires a large container and ample refrigerator space to accommodate the submerged turkey.
    • Can lead to a slightly less crispy skin due to the added moisture.
    • May require additional drying time before roasting to achieve crispy skin.

Dry Brining:

  • Pros:
    • Produces a crispier skin due to the moisture drawn out during the brining process.
    • Requires less refrigerator space as you’re only storing the dry-rubbed turkey.
    • Offers a more intense flavor concentration as the dry rub directly interacts with the meat.
  • Cons:
    • Can be a bit more challenging for beginners due to the handling of the raw turkey.
    • May require a longer brining time compared to wet brining.
    • Can result in a slightly less juicy turkey compared to wet brining.

Choosing the Right Brining Method for You

Now that you understand the key differences between wet and dry brining, it’s time to choose the method that aligns with your preferences and needs. Consider the following factors:

  • Refrigerator space: If you’re tight on space, dry brining might be the way to go.
  • Desired level of moisture: If you crave a super juicy turkey, wet brining is your best bet.
  • Flavor intensity: For a more intense flavor, dry brining takes the crown.
  • Crispiness preference: If you’re all about that crispy skin, dry brining is your champion.
  • Comfort level: If handling a raw turkey makes you squeamish, wet brining might be a more comfortable option.

Ultimately, the best brining method depends on your individual preferences and priorities.

Additional Tips for Brining Success

No matter which brining method you choose, here are some additional tips to ensure a perfectly brined turkey:

  • Start with a thawed turkey. This ensures even brining throughout the bird.
  • Use a food-grade container for wet brining. Avoid using materials that can leach chemicals into the brine.
  • Keep the brine cold. This is crucial for food safety.
  • Pat the turkey dry before roasting. This helps achieve crispy skin.
  • Don’t overcook the turkey. Overcooked turkey is dry and tough, regardless of the brining method.

Whether you’re a seasoned Thanksgiving pro or a first-timer, brining your turkey is a surefire way to elevate your holiday feast. By understanding the differences between wet and dry brining, you can choose the method that best suits your needs and preferences. With these tips and a little bit of love, you’ll be serving up a juicy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked turkey that will have your guests raving.

Why dry-brining results in the best turkey:

The wet-brining method involves some complex maneuvers. To start, you’ll need to find a large bucket or bag that the turkey can soak in. It’s a process prone to nightmarish outcomes (#throwback to when former Epi food editor Rhoda Boone ended up with a fridge flooded with turkey water). You’re far less likely to encounter such problems when making a dry-brined turkey. Either way, you’ll need to clear some space in the refrigerator because that’s just how Thanksgiving turkeys are.

Dry-brining has more going for it than mere user-friendliness. It also makes the skin of the turkey extra crispy. The skin dries out while the turkey is left uncovered in the refrigerator, which makes it crisp beautifully in the oven. Additionally, dry-brining ensures the turkey meat is penetrated with seasoning throughout.

When you dry-brine a bird, the salt draws out moisture from the turkey, causing the salt to dissolve. Once dissolved, the salt combines with those turkey juices and gets reabsorbed into the meat. Muscle proteins are broken down during the process, resulting in the most delicious, juicy, and well-seasoned turkey you’ve ever tasted—no bashing or buckets needed.

Dry brining vs. wet brining:

There are two ways to brine your Thanksgiving turkey: a wet brine or a dry brine. To dry brine a turkey, all you have to do is coat it with a mixture of herbs and salt and refrigerate it for several hours (about an hour for each pound). A little more complicated is wet brining, which calls for soaking a turkey for several hours or overnight in a salt-water solution that may also contain herbs, spices, and aromatics. Ale or molasses are occasionally added to the water.

PERFECT TURKEY Wet Brine and Dry Brine


Can I wet brine then dry brine turkey?

If you like the texture and juiciness of a wet-brined turkey but adore crispy skin, you can take your wet-brine process one step further and let your turkey dry in the fridge overnight.

Do you rinse a turkey after dry brining?

Pat It Dry Use paper towels and get the skin “as dry as possible” before doing anything else. And if you’re wondering, no—you don’t need to rinse the bird, whether it’s been dry-brined or wet-brined, before adding more seasoning and roasting.

Can you brine and dry rub a turkey?

Using a Turkey Rub The flavors infuse the meat and create a beautiful golden color on the skin. If using this along with a brine, you need to eliminate the salt from the rub recipe. Since most rub recipes contain salt, it is crucial that you cut out this ingredient.

Should a turkey be fully submerged in brine?

This dilutes the salt solution to the best ratio for brining and also helps further cool the solution. Make sure the turkey is completely submerged. If needed, prepare more brine solution at a ratio of 1/4 cup salt per quart of water to completely submerge the turkey. Cover and refrigerate.

Should you brine a Turkey?

The other thing to consider is the flavor impact of a wet brine. While wet brines are good at keeping a turkey moist, they don’t deliver on flavor. The turkey only takes on water and salt, and the aromatics added to the brining solution, despite what many people think, don’t absorb into the meat.

How do you brine a Thanksgiving turkey?

But let’s back up: There are two ways to brine your Thanksgiving turkey: a wet brine or a dry brine. Dry brining simply involves rubbing a turkey in a salt-and-herb mixture and letting it sit in the refrigerator for many hours (usually about one hour per pound).

What is wet brining a Turkey?

Wet brining is slightly more involved: it requires soaking a turkey in a salt-water solution (herbs, spices, and aromatics can be incorporated, and sometimes other liquids like beer or molasses are added to the water) for several hours or overnight. The wet-brining method involves some complex maneuvers.

How long do you keep a Turkey in a brine?

Keep it cold. Refrigerate your turkey (or keep it cold in your cooler) for 12-24 hours. Remove from the brine and pat dry. Refrigerate/chill again, this time uncovered for 12-24 more hours, to ensure crispier skin when cooked. A dry brine draws the moisture out of the meat and then resettles into itself as it cooks.

Leave a Comment