The Untold Truth of the Turkey Leg: A Journey from Medieval Fairs to Global Sensation

There aren’t many foods that divide people as much as turkey legs; you either love them or hate them. On one extreme of the spectrum, its devoted fans can’t get enough of the portable, heavily salted food that comes in large portions. However, those who despise it are skilled at disparaging it, pointing out its enormous, frequently hideous appearance as well as the incredible quantities of fat, calories, and who knows what else you’re consuming in one sitting. Haters gonna hate, right?.

The image of one has probably been ingrained in your memory for eternity, regardless of whether you have attempted one or were just a bystander. You just cant unsee the thing. The turkey leg has its place in many amusement parks, county fairs, and festivals across the country. Every year on National Turkey Lovers Day, its ardent supporters gather to celebrate the product (well, all turkey products really). On paper, it’s a snack made primarily of protein from the aforementioned animal, or a meal because, let’s be honest, it’s huge. So why does the bird receive so much heat? Come along on this fattening, enjoyable, and fair adventure with us! This is the untold truth of the turkey leg.

Where do giant turkey legs come from? This seemingly simple question has a surprisingly complex answer, spanning centuries and continents. While their presence at Renaissance festivals and amusement parks might make them seem like a modern invention, the turkey leg’s origins actually lie in the Medieval era, albeit not in the way you might imagine.

These festivals, popular since the early 1960s, recreate aspects of life in the Middle Ages, including the food. While turkey wasn’t a common European fare back then, the large, primal nature of the turkey leg made it a perfect fit for these celebrations, even if historically inaccurate.

Interestingly the largest turkey legs in the United States can be found at an Ohio Renaissance Festival. This festival boasts legs weighing nearly 2 pounds sourced from specially selected, large birds. This has even sparked controversy with animal rights groups like PETA.

But what exactly are these turkey legs? They come from the male turkey, whose legs are significantly larger than those of the female. The holiday turkey you enjoy is likely female, while males are used for commercial purposes like deli meats. The leg itself comprises the thigh and drumstick, making it a dark meat option.

While the turkey leg has been a staple at Renaissance fairs for decades, it was Disney Parks that brought it to global attention. Debuting in Walt Disney World in the 1980s, the turkey leg quickly became a popular snack, spreading to other Disney parks and eventually theme parks across the country.

Today, millions of turkey legs are sold annually at Disney parks alone. Their secret? A unique curing process that injects the legs with a salt and sugar solution, giving them a ham-like flavor and pink color.

Despite online rumors, these turkey legs are not made from emu. This myth was debunked by a Disney executive chef and further contradicted by celebrity chef Andrew Zimmern, who described emu as having a distinct, gamey flavor unlike turkey.

While the turkey leg might seem like a keto-friendly option, it’s actually a no-go due to the brown sugar used in the brine. This ingredient violates the keto diet’s strict low-carb guidelines.

For turkey leg enthusiasts, there’s a plethora of merchandise available, from t-shirts and hats to air fresheners. Disney even sells playful merchandise featuring a cartoon turkey leg with the slogan “Nice & Juicy.”

If you’re feeling adventurous, you can even make your own turkey leg at home. Numerous recipes are available online, allowing you to recreate the classic smoked flavor and juicy texture.

The turkey leg’s popularity has even inspired entire restaurants dedicated to this novelty. Turkey Leg Paradise in Dallas and Turkey Leg Hut in Houston offer giant smoked turkey legs alongside other unique dishes, drawing long lines and attracting celebrity attention.

From its humble beginnings at Renaissance fairs to its global fame, the turkey leg has become a cultural icon, sparking debate, inspiring merchandise, and even fueling entire restaurant concepts. Whether you love it or hate it, there’s no denying the untold truth of the turkey leg: it’s a culinary phenomenon with a surprisingly rich history.

The turkey leg’s origins are in Medieval times (but not what you may think)

Theres a lot that could be attributed to Medieval times — the time period from the 5th to the late 15th centuries also known as the Middle Ages. We have them to thank for countless leaps and bounds of advancements in agricultural and technological innovations. The turkey leg also has its origin in Medieval times, but not what you may think. Were talking Medieval fairs and Renaissance festivals.

Tracing back to the early 1960s, Renaissance festivals are a popular, albeit not historically accurate, way to celebrate yesteryear through re-enactments. These commercial gatherings are also known for serving a smorgasbord of food and drink inspired by the eras affinity for eating food with their hands — and are credited with introducing the masses to … the turkey leg. The sheer primal nature of a turkey leg is a perfect fit for the festivals even if the turkey leg wasnt common fare in Europe at the time. Sorry to say, but no, our ancestors were absolutely not chowing down on a drumstick full of turkey meat. Nevertheless, these Medieval celebrations are the first time the people got their grubby hands on the now infamous food.

Despite what you may think, they aren’t keto

The ketogenic diet has become extremely popular and well-known worldwide in recent years due to the support of numerous celebrities and large corporations. It is essentially an extremely low-carb diet that uses good fats and proteins rather than complex sugars and carbohydrates to fuel the body. On paper, a turkey leg should — in theory— fall under the guidelines. Sorry to say keto dieters, put down the turkey leg immediately.

Smoked meat is inherently a-okay on the diet, but its the popular preparation of the turkey leg that makes this one a big, fat no-no. According to a Reddit thread that deep dives into the recipe in question, the brine used in many popular preparations, including theme parks, has brown sugar in it. Brown sugar is without a doubt not okay on the keto diet. We were able to track down a copycat recipe for Disneys turkey leg and that confirmed our suspicions as over 1 table of dark brown sugar was used in the brine.

Top 10 UNTOLD TRUTHS of Disney’s Giant Turkey Legs

FAQ

Where did turkey legs originate?

The birds from Europe were much smaller turkey fowl but looked close enough to their larger brethren that after American settlement the name stuck. The origins of turkey leg popularity come mainly from renaissance fairs and medieval themed restaurants during the latter half of the 1900s.

Why are turkey legs so big at the fair?

We got you as we’re here to decipher and decode exactly what is our favorite fair food (boy, that’s almost as much of a mouth full as eating one.). These beefy boys actually come from male turkeys being that their legs are much larger than those of the female.

How big can turkey legs get?

Most turkey legs range in weight between 1.5- 2.5 pounds. They are 3-4 times the size of a traditional chicken leg drumstick.

Are turkey drumsticks the same as turkey legs?

A turkey leg is technically comprised of the bird’s thigh and the drumstick (the part of the leg below the knee joint), though in many recipes the term is used to refer to just the drumstick. Skin-on and bone-in, a full leg typically weighs between one and two and a half pounds.

What is a giant turkey leg?

The giant turkey leg — a shticky concession Renaissance fairs have served for years — popped up in Disney World for the first time in the late ’80s. It was originally only sold at one food cart, near Big Al’s in Magic Kingdom’s Frontierland. A turkey leg tips the scales at 1.5 pounds!

Where did the turkey leg come from?

Although turkey legs have lived quietly amongst the Renaissance Fair community (and its avid carnivores) since the 1960s, it was the house of the mouse that is credited with making it a household name. According to a New York Times piece, the turkey leg made its grand debut at Walt Disney World in Central Florida in the 1980s.

Who invented the turkey leg?

Believe it or not, the turkey leg made its debut in Magic Kingdom in 1989 thanks to a man by the name of Dave Jarrett. Originally an employee at Cap’n Jack’s in the Walt Disney World Village (widely known as Disney Springs today), Jarrett eventually worked his way through the ranks of Walt Disney World.

When did the giant turkey leg come out?

The giant turkey leg premiered in the late 1980’s with strong sales at Big Al’s Coonskin Caps in Frontierland at the Magic Kingdom. It wasn’t long before their popularity meant the turkey legs were made available at all six Disney parks in the US.

Leave a Comment