Why Do We Eat Corned Beef And Cabbage On St Patrick’S Day?

What has become a tradition of eating corned beef and cabbage to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day likely grew out of the fact that those foods were less expensive for immigrants who came to America. They substituted beef for pork and cabbage for potatoes.

The History of Corned Beef on St. Patrick’s Day

Despite being referred to as one of Ireland’s national dishes, corned beef actually originated in New York City. In Ireland, cattle have always been raised for milk, so beef has never been a common food. Bacon, often eaten with cabbage, was the Irish go-to meal. Irish immigrants in the early 1800s could not afford the price of pork, so they bought corned beef brisket from Jewish butchers on Manhattan’s Lower East Side instead. This cheaper meat was pickled, fermented, and preserved in crocks.

This inexpensive meat cut, known as “corns” because it was brined with large-grained salt crystals, wasn’t just popular among Irish people. Brining was a method of salt-curing meat used in Eastern Europe, and corned beef became common on many tables in the 1800s. It can be identified by the pink color that results from the months-long brining process in crocks used to help preserve the beef. Because the brisket was being pickled during the brining process, corned beef was occasionally even referred to as “pickled beef.”

Unexpectedly, neither the U.S. nor Canada’s restaurant menus regularly feature corned beef and cabbage. S. or Ireland other than on the days that surround St. Patrick’s Day. At Garden Spot Village, a retirement residence in New Holland, Pennsylvania, Mike Pezzillo serves as executive chef. Despite being a good cut of beef, he believes that corned beef isn’t more widely consumed because it takes a long time to prepare and cannot be served in small portions. Pezzillo also thinks that since corned beef isn’t a common menu item, people tend to cook what their mothers prepared or what they tasted and liked in a restaurant.

Like my culinary school classmates, I was shocked to learn about the Jewish connection to corned beef, Pezzillo said.

For St. Patrick’s Day, Pezzillo adds corned beef and cabbage to Garden Spot Village’s menu. Patrick’s Day, but also at other times throughout the year, he adds. ”.

Rory Dolan’s Restaurant Bar, a three-decade-old Irish eatery in Yonkers, New York, is a well-liked location for the meal on St. Patrick’s Day. On March 17, it is reputed to serve more than 1,500 plates of corned beef. Rory Dolan’s serves corned beef frequently throughout the year due to its popularity.

A misconception about corned beef is that it is pastrami, just cooked differently. However, that’s not the case. Pastrami and corned beef are prepared with different spices and have distinctly different tastes. The brine for corned beef and pastrami is the same mixture of salt, sugar, black pepper, cloves, coriander, bay leaves, juniper berries and dill, as well as the preservatives sodium nitrate or sodium nitrite, according to eater.com. But after brining, corned beef is boiled, while pastrami is usually smoked. They also are from different cuts of beef. Corned beef is the brisket, the lower front pectoral muscles of the cow. Pastrami can be cut from the shoulder, the navel or plate, and less often, from the brisket. And, pastrami is heavily rubbed with black pepper, coriander, mustard seeds, fennel seeds and sometimes fresh garlic before smoking. It is often eaten in a deli-style sandwich, on rye bread with a lot of mustard. Corned beef is boiled plain, and is often eaten with cabbage, potatoes and carrots, with utensils, and accompanied by Irish soda bread, an unsweetened quick bread.

Even if you haven’t had corned beef and cabbage at home or in a restaurant, there’s a good chance you’ve had a Reuben sandwich, which consists of grilled corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing between slices of rye bread. The sandwich is thought to have been created for Reuben Kulakofsky at the Blackstone Hotel in Omaha, Nebraska, during a regular poker game, in 1920.

Therefore, during the week of St. Patrick’s Day, it isn’t difficult to find corned beef if you want to give it a try. Patrick’s Day celebrations. There are numerous restaurants serving corned beef right now in southeast Pennsylvania, including McGrath’s in Harrisburg, McCleary’s Pub House in Marietta, Ugly Oyster in Reading, O’Rourke’s Eatery in Gettysburg, O’Halloran Irish Pub, and Annie Bailey’s Irish Public House in Lancaster.

Spring Taste of Ireland, a popular event hosted by the Irish American Cultural Society of Lancaster, will include classic dishes like shepherd’s pie, bangers and mash, and Guinness stew. However, according to Tom Daniels, the festival’s president, corned beef and cabbage are not served.

A little-known fact about corned beef and cabbage is that it was a favorite dish of our 16th president, Abraham Lincoln, who served it at his 1861 inauguration dinner. If you’re still wondering what the big fuss is about after learning all this new information about it, consider that it has only been consumed by Irish immigrants more than 100 years ago and Irish partygoers today.

Find a family-favorite version of the recipe below.

This recipe makes 6 servings.

  • 3-4 pound corned beef brisket
  • 1 chopped onion
  • 2 cloves garlic, minced
  • 2 bay leaves
  • 6 medium potatoes, pared
  • 6 small carrots, pared
  • 6 cabbage wedges

One 3–4 pound corned beef brisket should be placed fat side up in a Dutch oven with water covering it.

Add the bay leaves, onion, and garlic; cover and simmer for 4 hours until tender.

Remove meat from the liquid; keep warm.

The pot with the corned beef should now have potatoes and carrots in it. Cover and bring to boiling; cook 10 minutes.

Add cabbage wedges; cook 20 minutes longer.

Glaze meat while vegetables cook.


  • Prepared mustard
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar
  • Dash cloves

Put the corned beef in a roasting pan. Spread the prepared mustard on the meat’s fat side to create the glaze. Sprinkle some brown sugar and cloves on it after that. For 15 to 20 minutes, bake the corned beef in a shallow pan in a 350°F oven.

The meat ought to be so tender that a knife should barely be needed to cut it. Most of the fat is rendered during the cooking process.

This recipe stands out among the others thanks to the glaze, which provides an additional flavor layer.

Success! An email containing a confirmation link for the list signup was sent to.

Error! There was an error processing your request.

What To Read Next

On this week’s hemp podcast, we speak with Hannah Smith-Brubaker from Pasa Sustainable Agriculture, Jonathan Miller from the US Hemp Roundtable, and Chris Allen from Hemp Federation Ireland.

Maryland’s secretary of agriculture, Joseph Bartenfelder, talks about a hectic month for farmers there.

In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, Art Petrosemolo works as a freelance correspondent and photojournalist. ;.

Why do we eat corned beef on St. Patrick’s Day?


Where did the corned beef and cabbage tradition come from?

According to experts, the dish was created on American soil in the late 19th century when Irish immigrants replaced the bacon, which was the preferred meat in the homeland, with corned beef.

What is the traditional meal eaten on St Patrick’s Day?

On St. Patrick’s Day, corned beef and cabbage is the most popular dish, frequently accompanied by one or two green beers. On March 17, the dish known as “boiled dinner” and its accompanying liquid predominate the menus of Irish bars and eateries across the nation. Many home cooks also serve the dish.

Why is corned beef and cabbage good luck?

On New Year’s Day, many people of Irish ancestry make corned beef and cabbage. It relates to the good fortune you should anticipate in the upcoming year. Because these animals do not forage in the mud for food like chickens do, beef or pork is the preferred meat.

Leave a Comment